Research:RatingHub/YT/SocialismForAll - Revision history

Reversedragon: /* Motifs */ use classname template

2025-07-25T08:37:45Z

Motifs: use classname template

← Older revision		Revision as of 08:37, 25 July 2025
Line 29:		Line 29:
	== Motifs ==		== Motifs ==

	<ol class="hue clean">		<!-- {{HueCSS}} --><ol class="hue clean">
	</li><li class~~="field_ML"~~ value="618~~" data-dimension="S2~~">Right-Liberalism is the shovel dream of capitalism <ref name="cn-k" />		</li><li {{IS2/ML/class}} value="618">Right-Liberalism is the shovel dream of capitalism <ref name="cn-k" />
	</li><li class~~="field_ML"~~ value="618~~" data-dimension="S2~~">Socialist transition is not New York being affordable / Socialism is not New York being affordable <ref name="cn-k" />		</li><li {{IS2/ML/class}} value="618">Socialist transition is not New York being affordable / Socialism is not New York being affordable <ref name="cn-k" />
	</li><li class~~="field_ML"~~ value="618~~" data-dimension="S2~~">Free buses don't lead to Bolshevism <ref name="cn-k" />		</li><li {{IS2/ML/class}} value="618">Free buses don't lead to Bolshevism <ref name="cn-k" />
	</li><li class~~="field_ML"~~ value="618~~" data-dimension="Z~~">killing of Indonesian Communists 1965-1966 <ref name="cn-k" />		</li><li {{IZ1/ML/class}} value="618">killing of Indonesian Communists 1965-1966 <ref name="cn-k" />
	</li><li class~~="field_ML"~~ value="618~~" data-dimension="Z~~">killing of Allende <ref name="cn-k" />		</li><li {{IZ1/ML/class}} value="618">killing of Allende <ref name="cn-k" />
	</li><li class~~="field_ML"~~ value="618~~" data-dimension="S2~~">Zohran Mamdani is not using Marxist methods <ref name="cn-k" /> -> I haven't been following news much but yeah, I already believe it.		</li><li {{IS2/ML/class}} value="618">Zohran Mamdani is not using Marxist methods <ref name="cn-k" /> -> I haven't been following news much but yeah, I already believe it.
	</li><li class~~="field_ML"~~ value="2145~~" data-dimension="S2~~">Trotskyism is the shovel dream of small owners / Trotskyism is the shovel dream of Artisan types / Trotskyism is the shovel dream of the petty bourgeosie <ref name="4v-4" /> -> I think this is only half the explanation but I can't disagree. I think you have to model it as the shovel dream of a separate unique cluster of "petty bourgeoisie", a subpopulation as a countable object, to where there can be plural groups which fail to unify because they're fundamentally separate objects. but at that point you've basically got it.		</li><li {{IS2/ML/class}} value="2145">Trotskyism is the shovel dream of small owners / Trotskyism is the shovel dream of Artisan types / Trotskyism is the shovel dream of the petty bourgeosie <ref name="4v-4" /> -> I think this is only half the explanation but I can't disagree. I think you have to model it as the shovel dream of a separate unique cluster of "petty bourgeoisie", a subpopulation as a countable object, to where there can be plural groups which fail to unify because they're fundamentally separate objects. but at that point you've basically got it.
	</ol>		</li></ol>

	=== Audiobooks ===		=== Audiobooks ===
Line 43:		Line 43:
	<ol class="hue clean">		<ol class="hue clean">
	</li><li class="field_ML" value="2144" data-dimension="S2"><cite>Trotskyism: Counter-revolution in Disguise</cite> (Olgin 1935) <ref name="4v-4" />		</li><li class="field_ML" value="2144" data-dimension="S2"><cite>Trotskyism: Counter-revolution in Disguise</cite> (Olgin 1935) <ref name="4v-4" />
	</ol>		</li></ol>

	== Additional remarks ==		== Additional remarks ==

Reversedragon: Trotskyism: Counter-revolution in Disguise

2025-07-25T05:26:54Z

Trotskyism: Counter-revolution in Disguise

← Older revision		Revision as of 05:26, 25 July 2025
Line 13:		Line 13:
	{{HueRoster\|EP=P34\| [[E:mainstream Marxism-Leninism\|mainstream Marxism-Leninism]] \| popular level material }}		{{HueRoster\|EP=P34\| [[E:mainstream Marxism-Leninism\|mainstream Marxism-Leninism]] \| popular level material }}
	{{HueRoster\|P=approximate number of entries\| {{TTS\|~\|around\|title=around}}1,000 }}		{{HueRoster\|P=approximate number of entries\| {{TTS\|~\|around\|title=around}}1,000 }}
	{{HueRoster\|P=overall rating\| {{U}} \|endlist=y}}		{{HueRoster\|P=overall rating\| {{U}} \|endlist=y}} [[Category:Source communication rating sheets]]

	== Rating sheet ==		== Rating sheet ==

	<dl class="wikitable hue data_rating"><!-- ex.: {{E:P203/G}} -->		<dl class="wikitable hue data_rating"><!-- ex.: {{E:P203/G}} -->
	{{WorkRating\| {{YouTube\|cnmoa1BxVik\|Both Can Be True: Thoughts on the Zohran Mamdani Discussion ...}} (video NN) \|G={{G}}\|RR=~~4631~~\|Q=1\| {{E:P202/G}} \|endlist=y}}		{{WorkRating\| {{YouTube\|cnmoa1BxVik\|Both Can Be True: Thoughts on the Zohran Mamdani Discussion ...}} (video 1000) \|G={{G}}\|RR=6687\|Q=1\| {{E:P202/G}} }}
			{{WorkRating\| {{YouTube\|--\|Invigoration of the Life of the Party Is the Main Problem (Hoxha 1966)}} (video 999) \|G={{U}}\|RR=6687\|Q=0\| -- }}
			{{WorkRating\| {{YouTube\|--\|Zohran Mamdani Starts to Integrate with the Democratic Party Establishment & NYC Union Bureaucracy}} (video 998) \|G={{G}}\|RR=6687\|Q=0\| -- }}
			{{WorkRating\| {{YouTube\|--\|Lavender & Red (Parts 34-36) (Feinberg 2005)}} (video 997) \|G={{U}}\|RR=6687\|Q=0\| -- }}
			{{WorkRating\| ... \|G=hr}}
			{{WorkRating\| {{YouTube\|4vzgY8MvPO4\|Trotskyism: Counter-revolution in Disguise, Ch. 1-4 (M. J. Olgin 1935)}} (video NNN) \|G={{G}}\|RR=6687\|Q=1\| {{E:P202/G}} }}
			{{WorkRating\| ... \|G=hr}}
			{{WorkRating\| (unknown video) (video 1) \|G={{U}}\|RR=6687\|Q=0\| -- \|endlist=y}}

	== Motifs ==		== Motifs ==
Line 29:		Line 36:
	</li><li class="field_ML" value="618" data-dimension="Z">killing of Allende <ref name="cn-k" />		</li><li class="field_ML" value="618" data-dimension="Z">killing of Allende <ref name="cn-k" />
	</li><li class="field_ML" value="618" data-dimension="S2">Zohran Mamdani is not using Marxist methods <ref name="cn-k" /> -> I haven't been following news much but yeah, I already believe it.		</li><li class="field_ML" value="618" data-dimension="S2">Zohran Mamdani is not using Marxist methods <ref name="cn-k" /> -> I haven't been following news much but yeah, I already believe it.
			</li><li class="field_ML" value="2145" data-dimension="S2">Trotskyism is the shovel dream of small owners / Trotskyism is the shovel dream of Artisan types / Trotskyism is the shovel dream of the petty bourgeosie <ref name="4v-4" /> -> I think this is only half the explanation but I can't disagree. I think you have to model it as the shovel dream of a separate unique cluster of "petty bourgeoisie", a subpopulation as a countable object, to where there can be plural groups which fail to unify because they're fundamentally separate objects. but at that point you've basically got it.
			</ol>

			=== Audiobooks ===

			<ol class="hue clean">
			</li><li class="field_ML" value="2144" data-dimension="S2"><cite>Trotskyism: Counter-revolution in Disguise</cite> (Olgin 1935) <ref name="4v-4" />
	</ol>		</ol>

Line 38:		Line 52:

	<references>		<references>
	<ref name="cn-k"><cite class="article">Both Can Be True: Thoughts on the Zohran Mamdani Discussion</cite> {{YouTube\|cnmoa1BxVik}}</ref>		<ref name="cn-k"><cite class="article">Both Can Be True: Thoughts on the Zohran Mamdani Discussion</cite> {{YouTube\|cnmoa1BxVik}}</ref>
			<ref name="4v-4"><cite class="article">Trotskyism: Counter-revolution in Disguise</cite> (audiobook) {{YouTube\|4vzgY8MvPO4}} {{YouTube\|Ma_i9ygHwC4}} {{YouTube\|kC78fAEUOI4}} {{YouTube\|X2CbCRtr1LQ}} {{YouTube\|9oObW5VcvzA}} {{YouTube\|9J4oqPvMWDI}} {{YouTube\|PBpdCWJBmak}} {{YouTube\|k0T2WYdMpnc}} {{YouTube\|BoRct08zsdk}} {{YouTube\|4KujovKnTek}}</ref>
	</references>		</references>


	~~[[Category:Source communication rating sheets]]~~

Reversedragon: Reversedragon moved page User:Reversedragon/RatingHub/YT/SocialismForAll to Philosophical Research:RatingHub/YT/SocialismForAll: Entity number or thesis portal structure was not final

2025-07-25T00:01:36Z

Reversedragon moved page User:Reversedragon/RatingHub/YT/SocialismForAll to Philosophical Research:RatingHub/YT/SocialismForAll: Entity number or thesis portal structure was not final

← Older revision	Revision as of 00:01, 25 July 2025
(No difference)

Reversedragon: copy or update rating sheet from daemonsultanump

2025-07-24T23:53:27Z

copy or update rating sheet from daemonsultanump

New page

__FORCETOC__ <h2 class="toc-only">Background</h2>

<strong>Rating subject:</strong> YouTube video channel <strong>[https://invidious.nerdvpn.de/channel/UC5GYwuvmAD_VyV6w5aFnnUw @SocialismForAll]</strong>

* This is a Marxist theory channel.
* This channel attempts to describe a generic method for building [[E:Having a movement is half the battle|properly-Marxist workers' movements]] without taking the side of particular named Marxisms. Because it is already attempting to take a "[[E:meta-Marxism|meta]]" position on Marxism, it should be rated for [[Term:sound argument|accuracy to the material world]] and given bad marks for all failures to describe what is actually happening and what people can actually expect on the ground.
* This channel contains audiobooks. Parts of the channel constitute a reading list, which may be worth coding as Items.
* This channel mentions Lenin, Stalin, and Hoxha in the context of relevant theorists or sources.

{{HueCSS}}
<dl class="wikitable hue">
{{HueRoster|EP=P34| [[E:mainstream Marxism-Leninism|mainstream Marxism-Leninism]] | popular level material }}
{{HueRoster|P=approximate number of entries| {{TTS|~|around|title=around}}1,000 }}
{{HueRoster|P=overall rating| {{U}} |endlist=y}}

== Rating sheet ==

<dl class="wikitable hue data_rating">
{{WorkRating| {{YouTube|cnmoa1BxVik|Both Can Be True: Thoughts on the Zohran Mamdani Discussion ...}} (video NN) |G={{G}}|RR=4631|Q=1| {{E:P202/G}} |endlist=y}}

== Motifs ==

<ol class="hue clean">
</li><li class="field_ML" value="618" data-dimension="S2">Right-Liberalism is the shovel dream of capitalism <ref name="cn-k" />
</li><li class="field_ML" value="618" data-dimension="S2">Socialist transition is not New York being affordable / Socialism is not New York being affordable <ref name="cn-k" />
</li><li class="field_ML" value="618" data-dimension="S2">Free buses don't lead to Bolshevism <ref name="cn-k" />
</li><li class="field_ML" value="618" data-dimension="Z">killing of Indonesian Communists 1965-1966 <ref name="cn-k" />
</li><li class="field_ML" value="618" data-dimension="Z">killing of Allende <ref name="cn-k" />
</li><li class="field_ML" value="618" data-dimension="S2">Zohran Mamdani is not using Marxist methods <ref name="cn-k" /> -> I haven't been following news much but yeah, I already believe it.
</ol>

== Additional remarks ==

* This channel tends to look harshly on figures that describe large social-democracy organizations as The Bureaucracy. <ref name="cn-k" />

== References ==

<references>
<ref name="cn-k"><cite class="article">Both Can Be True: Thoughts on the Zohran Mamdani Discussion</cite> {{YouTube|cnmoa1BxVik}}</ref>
</references>

[[Category:Source communication rating sheets]]