Jump to content

User:RD/9k/Q39,99: Difference between revisions

From Philosophical Research
copy markup from 9k/Q29,38
 
m Q60,44 bad, fake history
 
(One intermediate revision by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{NextNineThousand|PPPA=beyond in the hyper-future|User=RD|E=Q39,99|Contents=y}}
{{NextNineThousand|PPPA=beyond in the hyper-future|User=RD|E=Q39,99|Contents=y}}
== Main entry ==
== Main entries ==
 
=== Q39,99 ===
{{HueCSS}}<ol class="hue clean">
{{HueCSS}}<ol class="hue clean">


</li><li data-qid="39,99" value="3999" class="field_exstruct" data-dimension="S">beyond the end of history in the hyper-future / Communism as bad fake historical period  ->  the motif of real history versus fake historical periods applied to workers' states. usually a workers' state is asserted to be a "fake" historical period for reasons having to do with central government; that seems somewhat more common than it being based on fine-grained social structure. people will pinpoint one figurehead or a tiny council of people as a reason to attack a whole population.
{{li|start=y|I=S1/IV|Q=60,44|Q2=6044}}fake historical period / fake, bad history  -> the motif of bad events in history being treated as a detour from "real" history. this motif is orange because, quite honestly, this is exactly what the Trotskyite conspiracy was alleging against Stalin's government, whether you commandeer Zinovievism as supposedly being Liberalism or whether you interpret it as saying Trotskyism is the real history. (my response, always: then why hasn't it happened yet??) famously this motif also comes up in the Christian bible, with the hypothetical reign of the antichrist being a kind of fake historical period, or the reign of the Roman emperors being suggested as one.
 
{{li|I=S1/ES|Q=39,99|Q2=3999}}beyond the end of history in the hyper-future / Communism as bad fake historical period  ->  the motif of real history versus fake historical periods applied to workers' states. usually a workers' state is asserted to be a "fake" historical period for reasons having to do with central government; that seems somewhat more common than it being based on fine-grained social structure. people will pinpoint one figurehead or a tiny council of people as a reason to attack a whole population.


</li><li data-qid="39,98" value="3998" class="field_exstruct" data-dimension="S">reverting from the anomalous hyper-future to the past
{{li|I=S1/ES|Q=39,99|Q2=3999}}bad, fake historical period / fake, bad history / beyond the end of history in the hyper-future / Communism as bad fake historical period  ->  there's no good distinction between these. these should probably just be sense labels of the same Item.


</li></ol>
</li></ol>
== Positive reasons ==
 
=== Q39,98 ===
{{liAZ|I=S1/ES|Q=39,98|Q2=3998|PPPA = reverting from the anomalous hyper-future to the past }}
 
== Related ==
<!--
<ol class="hue clean">
<ol class="hue clean">
</li></ol><!--
</li></ol>--><!--


== Wavebuilder combinations ==
== Wavebuilder combinations ==
Line 18: Line 27:
--></dl>
--></dl>


== Ideologies ==
== Ideologies or fields ==


* (none)
* HAS / Christian bible
* IV / early Trotskyism
* ES / anticommunism


<!--== Full title for bookmarks (optional) ==
<!--== Full title for bookmarks (optional) ==

Latest revision as of 05:46, 15 March 2026

Main entries[edit]

Q39,99[edit]

  1. fake historical period / fake, bad history -> the motif of bad events in history being treated as a detour from "real" history. this motif is orange because, quite honestly, this is exactly what the Trotskyite conspiracy was alleging against Stalin's government, whether you commandeer Zinovievism as supposedly being Liberalism or whether you interpret it as saying Trotskyism is the real history. (my response, always: then why hasn't it happened yet??) famously this motif also comes up in the Christian bible, with the hypothetical reign of the antichrist being a kind of fake historical period, or the reign of the Roman emperors being suggested as one.
  2. beyond the end of history in the hyper-future / Communism as bad fake historical period -> the motif of real history versus fake historical periods applied to workers' states. usually a workers' state is asserted to be a "fake" historical period for reasons having to do with central government; that seems somewhat more common than it being based on fine-grained social structure. people will pinpoint one figurehead or a tiny council of people as a reason to attack a whole population.
  3. bad, fake historical period / fake, bad history / beyond the end of history in the hyper-future / Communism as bad fake historical period -> there's no good distinction between these. these should probably just be sense labels of the same Item.

Q39,98[edit]

  1. reverting from the anomalous hyper-future to the past

Related[edit]

Ideologies or fields[edit]

  • HAS / Christian bible
  • IV / early Trotskyism
  • ES / anticommunism