Philosophical Research:RatingHub/YT/SocialismForAll: Difference between revisions
copy or update rating sheet from daemonsultanump |
m →Motifs: use classname template |
||
| (2 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 13: | Line 13: | ||
{{HueRoster|EP=P34| [[E:mainstream Marxism-Leninism|mainstream Marxism-Leninism]] | popular level material }} | {{HueRoster|EP=P34| [[E:mainstream Marxism-Leninism|mainstream Marxism-Leninism]] | popular level material }} | ||
{{HueRoster|P=approximate number of entries| {{TTS|~|around|title=around}}1,000 }} | {{HueRoster|P=approximate number of entries| {{TTS|~|around|title=around}}1,000 }} | ||
{{HueRoster|P=overall rating| {{U}} |endlist=y}} | {{HueRoster|P=overall rating| {{U}} |endlist=y}} [[Category:Source communication rating sheets]] | ||
== Rating sheet == | == Rating sheet == | ||
<dl class="wikitable hue data_rating"><!-- ex.: {{E:P203/G}} --> | <dl class="wikitable hue data_rating"><!-- ex.: {{E:P203/G}} --> | ||
{{WorkRating| {{YouTube|cnmoa1BxVik|Both Can Be True: Thoughts on the Zohran Mamdani Discussion ...}} (video | {{WorkRating| {{YouTube|cnmoa1BxVik|Both Can Be True: Thoughts on the Zohran Mamdani Discussion ...}} (video 1000) |G={{G}}|RR=6687|Q=1| {{E:P202/G}} }} | ||
{{WorkRating| {{YouTube|--|Invigoration of the Life of the Party Is the Main Problem (Hoxha 1966)}} (video 999) |G={{U}}|RR=6687|Q=0| -- }} | |||
{{WorkRating| {{YouTube|--|Zohran Mamdani Starts to Integrate with the Democratic Party Establishment & NYC Union Bureaucracy}} (video 998) |G={{G}}|RR=6687|Q=0| -- }} | |||
{{WorkRating| {{YouTube|--|Lavender & Red (Parts 34-36) (Feinberg 2005)}} (video 997) |G={{U}}|RR=6687|Q=0| -- }} | |||
{{WorkRating| ... |G=hr}} | |||
{{WorkRating| {{YouTube|4vzgY8MvPO4|Trotskyism: Counter-revolution in Disguise, Ch. 1-4 (M. J. Olgin 1935)}} (video NNN) |G={{G}}|RR=6687|Q=1| {{E:P202/G}} }} | |||
{{WorkRating| ... |G=hr}} | |||
{{WorkRating| (unknown video) (video 1) |G={{U}}|RR=6687|Q=0| -- |endlist=y}} | |||
== Motifs == | == Motifs == | ||
<!-- {{HueCSS}} --><ol class="hue clean"> | |||
</li><li {{IS2/ML/class}} value="618">Right-Liberalism is the shovel dream of capitalism <ref name="cn-k" /> | |||
</li><li {{IS2/ML/class}} value="618">Socialist transition is not New York being affordable / Socialism is not New York being affordable <ref name="cn-k" /> | |||
</li><li {{IS2/ML/class}} value="618">Free buses don't lead to Bolshevism <ref name="cn-k" /> | |||
</li><li {{IZ1/ML/class}} value="618">killing of Indonesian Communists 1965-1966 <ref name="cn-k" /> | |||
</li><li {{IZ1/ML/class}} value="618">killing of Allende <ref name="cn-k" /> | |||
</li><li {{IS2/ML/class}} value="618">Zohran Mamdani is not using Marxist methods <ref name="cn-k" /> -> I haven't been following news much but yeah, I already believe it. | |||
</li><li {{IS2/ML/class}} value="2145">Trotskyism is the shovel dream of small owners / Trotskyism is the shovel dream of Artisan types / Trotskyism is the shovel dream of the petty bourgeosie <ref name="4v-4" /> -> I think this is only half the explanation but I can't disagree. I think you have to model it as the shovel dream of a separate unique cluster of "petty bourgeoisie", a subpopulation as a countable object, to where there can be plural groups which fail to unify because they're fundamentally separate objects. but at that point you've basically got it. | |||
</li></ol> | |||
=== Audiobooks === | |||
<ol class="hue clean"> | <ol class="hue clean"> | ||
</li><li class="field_ML" value=" | </li><li class="field_ML" value="2144" data-dimension="S2"><cite>Trotskyism: Counter-revolution in Disguise</cite> (Olgin 1935) <ref name="4v-4" /> | ||
</li></ol> | |||
< | |||
</ | |||
</li> | |||
</ol> | |||
== Additional remarks == | == Additional remarks == | ||
| Line 38: | Line 52: | ||
<references> | <references> | ||
<ref name="cn-k"><cite class="article">Both Can Be True: Thoughts on the Zohran Mamdani Discussion</cite> {{YouTube|cnmoa1BxVik}}</ref> | <ref name="cn-k"><cite class="article">Both Can Be True: Thoughts on the Zohran Mamdani Discussion</cite> {{YouTube|cnmoa1BxVik}}</ref> | ||
<ref name="4v-4"><cite class="article">Trotskyism: Counter-revolution in Disguise</cite> (audiobook) {{YouTube|4vzgY8MvPO4}} {{YouTube|Ma_i9ygHwC4}} {{YouTube|kC78fAEUOI4}} {{YouTube|X2CbCRtr1LQ}} {{YouTube|9oObW5VcvzA}} {{YouTube|9J4oqPvMWDI}} {{YouTube|PBpdCWJBmak}} {{YouTube|k0T2WYdMpnc}} {{YouTube|BoRct08zsdk}} {{YouTube|4KujovKnTek}}</ref> | |||
</references> | </references> | ||
Latest revision as of 08:37, 25 July 2025
Background
Rating subject: YouTube video channel @SocialismForAll
- This is a Marxist theory channel.
- This channel attempts to describe a generic method for building properly-Marxist workers' movements without taking the side of particular named Marxisms. Because it is already attempting to take a "meta" position on Marxism, it should be rated for accuracy to the material world and given bad marks for all failures to describe what is actually happening and what people can actually expect on the ground.
- This channel contains audiobooks. Parts of the channel constitute a reading list, which may be worth coding as Items.
- This channel mentions Lenin, Stalin, and Hoxha in the context of relevant theorists or sources.
- field, scope, or group [Item]
- mainstream Marxism-Leninism
- popular level material
- approximate number of entries
- pronounced ~1,000
Rating sheet[edit]
Motifs[edit]
- Right-Liberalism is the shovel dream of capitalism [1]
- Socialist transition is not New York being affordable / Socialism is not New York being affordable [1]
- Free buses don't lead to Bolshevism [1]
- killing of Indonesian Communists 1965-1966 [1]
- killing of Allende [1]
- Zohran Mamdani is not using Marxist methods [1] -> I haven't been following news much but yeah, I already believe it.
- Trotskyism is the shovel dream of small owners / Trotskyism is the shovel dream of Artisan types / Trotskyism is the shovel dream of the petty bourgeosie [2] -> I think this is only half the explanation but I can't disagree. I think you have to model it as the shovel dream of a separate unique cluster of "petty bourgeoisie", a subpopulation as a countable object, to where there can be plural groups which fail to unify because they're fundamentally separate objects. but at that point you've basically got it.
Audiobooks[edit]
- Trotskyism: Counter-revolution in Disguise (Olgin 1935) [2]
Additional remarks[edit]
- This channel tends to look harshly on figures that describe large social-democracy organizations as The Bureaucracy. [1]