Ontology talk:9k/RD/Q47,78: Difference between revisions

Latest revision as of 14:06, 3 August 2026

Main entry

Trotskyism is like cold fusion
-> it would be so useful if it was possible but it never comes to be.

if cold fusion becomes possible before Trotskyism in one country, then this statement is false.

Trotskyism is like livermorium
— it's really big, but it falls apart and disappears immediately before it can even be observed
world where Trotskyists surpass North Korea
/ world where Trotskyists have made as much material progress in the world as North Korea -> this one hurts, doesn't it. they can't stand tiny fortress states that have various kinds of suffering imposed on them by First World empires, and often try to pin that on "the Stalinists" so they have someone to attack. but it's a somewhat indisputable fact that — reversion toward capitalism or none — North Koreans have done more socialist transition in their overall history than Trotskyists ever have.
your meta-Marxism is literally just Stalinism / (9k) -> these entries may have been a bit too mean.
then again, looking back at James P. Cannon's letter... Trotskyism fared really badly during WWII. when you look at it all from a distance, what it starts to look like is Trotskyists failed in Europe, the Axis powers were stronger, Stalin's Marxism had to take over the area to be able to defeat the Axis powers leading to it fighting off Trotskyism like a glorified anarchism, but because the Axis powers were so strong, capitalism had already prepared a huge cluster of center-Liberal armies that was stronger than Stalin's Marxism when combined and then both Marxisms were defeated. World War II was so bad that like, it was almost a 'medieval' war between archaic classes that had nothing to do with Marxism, like the regional wars between local-states before kingdoms only much more deadly. what do you even do if that's happening? there are many conflicts that Marxism has to simply understand have nothing to do with the central topics of Marxism that bring Marxism into existence. and yet if this stuff really doesn't concern Marxism, how do you ever win against capitalism when it's one of the strongest things in the universe despite being one of the most fragile and fractured things there is?
A letter to Trotskyists throughout the world [1] [2]

Ideology codes

(none)

Full title for bookmarks (optional)

[9k] Trotskyism is like cold fusion - Q47,78;4778 ; Trotskyism is like cold fusion ; Trotskyism is like livermorium ; world where Trotskyists surpass North Korea

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
-{{NextNineThousand|PPPA=Existentialist-Structuralist tradition|User=RD|E=Q47,78|Contents=y}}
+{{NextNineThousand|PPPA=Trotskyism is like cold fusion|User=RD|E=Q47,78|Contents=y}}
 == Main entry ==
 {{HueCSS}}<ol class="hue clean">
-<!-- {{li|start=y|I=S2/ES|tradition=LR, ES|Q=618}} -->
-<li class="field_trotsky" value="4778" data-dimension="S2">Trotskyism is like cold fusion  ->  it would be so useful if it was possible but it never comes to be.<br />
+{{li|start=y|I=S2/MX|tradition=MX onto IV|Q=4778|Q2=4778|h4 = Trotskyism is like cold fusion }}  ->  it would be so useful if it was possible but it never comes to be.<br />
 if cold fusion becomes possible before Trotskyism in one country, then this statement is false.
@@ Line 10: / Line 9: @@
 == Related ==
-<!--
 <ol class="hue clean">
-</li></ol> -->
+{{li|start=y|I=S2/ML|tradition=MX onto IV|Q=47,79|Q2=4779|h4=Trotskyism is like livermorium}} — it's really big, but it falls apart and disappears immediately before it can even be observed
+{{li|I=S1/ML|tradition=MX onto IV|Q=47,85|Q=4785|h4 = world where Trotskyists surpass North Korea }} / world where Trotskyists have made as much material progress in the world as North Korea  ->  this one hurts, doesn't it. they can't stand tiny fortress states that have various kinds of suffering imposed on them by First World empires, and often try to pin that on "the Stalinists" so they have someone to attack. but it's a somewhat indisputable fact that — reversion toward capitalism or none — North Koreans have done more socialist transition in their overall history than Trotskyists ever have.
+{{li|I=S1/MX|Q=70,44|Q2=7044}}your meta-Marxism is literally just Stalinism / ({{9k|RD/Q7044}})  ->  these entries may have been a bit too mean.<br/>
+then again, looking back at James P. Cannon's letter... Trotskyism fared {{em|really badly}} during WWII. when you look at it all from a distance, what it starts to look like is Trotskyists failed in Europe, the Axis powers were stronger, Stalin's Marxism had to take over the area to be able to defeat the Axis powers leading to it fighting off Trotskyism like a glorified anarchism, but because the Axis powers were so strong, capitalism had already prepared a huge cluster of center-Liberal armies that was stronger than Stalin's Marxism when combined and then both Marxisms were defeated. World War II was so bad that like, it was almost a 'medieval' war between archaic classes that had nothing to do with Marxism, like the regional wars between local-states before kingdoms only much more deadly. what do you even do if that's happening? there are many conflicts that Marxism has to simply understand have nothing to do with the central topics of Marxism that bring Marxism into existence. and yet if this stuff really doesn't concern Marxism, how do you ever win against capitalism when it's one of the strongest things in the universe despite being one of the most fragile and fractured things there is?
+{{li|I=Z1/MX|Q=43,53|Q2=4353}}A letter to Trotskyists throughout the world [https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2008/10/open-o21.html] {{a|title=A letter to Trotskyists throughout the world|href=https://archive.is/JCdgs}}
+</li></ol>
 == Ideology codes ==
@@ Line 18: / Line 26: @@
 * (none)
+== Full title for bookmarks (optional) ==
+<pre>[9k] Trotskyism is like cold fusion - Q47,78;4778 ; Trotskyism is like cold fusion ; Trotskyism is like livermorium ; world where Trotskyists surpass North Korea</pre>
 [[Category:Next nine thousand (RD)]]  <!-- page ends here.  TTS-unfriendly numbers incoming
-redirects:   [[Ontology_talk:9k/RD/Q4778]]
+redirects:   [[Ontology talk:9k/RD/Q4778]]
 duplication hint:   copy markup from [[Special:PermanentLink/NNNN|9k/Q47,78]] -->