Jump to content

Ontology talk:9k/RD/Q618-TheJamesPCannonOfBritain/x01: Difference between revisions

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From LithoGraphica
Reversedragon (talk | contribs)
Bureaucrats, Conference pass, Interface administrators, Arts-aligned editors, Crimson-aligned editors, Violet-aligned editors, Administrators
17,196 edits
copy markup from BordigismNotActuallyMarxism
 
Reversedragon (talk | contribs)
Bureaucrats, Conference pass, Interface administrators, Arts-aligned editors, Crimson-aligned editors, Violet-aligned editors, Administrators
17,196 edits
motifs
 
Line 1: Line 1:
{{ArticleTitle|h1=9k:RD/TheJamesPCannonOfBritain/01 (Q618)}}
{{ArticleTitle|h1=9k:RD/TheJamesPCannonOfBritain/01 (Q618)}}
<!--== Question ==
== Prompt ==
<ol class="hue clean  {{int:hue-ixn-classname-ES}}">
{{li|start=y|I=S2/HAS|tradition=|Q=618|Q2=618}}
</li></ol>
-->
== Prompt 1 ==
{{HueCSS}}<blockquote class="verbose">
{{HueCSS}}<blockquote class="verbose">
{{testimony|Was there anyone close to being a counterpart of James P. Cannon in Britain, in terms of their level of knowledge on Marxist analysis and their political positions?}}<!--
{{testimony|Was there anyone close to being a counterpart of James P. Cannon in Britain, in terms of their level of knowledge on Marxist analysis and their political positions?}}<!--
{{correction|[placeholder]}} -->
{{correction|[placeholder]}} -->
</blockquote>
</blockquote>
<!--
 
== Motifs or claims ==
<ol class="hue clean reset  {{int:hue-ixn-classname-ES}}">
 
{{li|start=y|I=Z1/IV|Q=618|Q2=618}}James P. Cannon / Jim Cannon (Healy) [https://www.wsws.org/en/special/library/healy/10.html]
 
{{li|I=S1/MX|Q=618|Q2=618}}the James Cannon of Britain / the James P. Cannon of Britain / [... prompt] (question)
 
</li></ol>
 
=== Response ===
<ol class="hue clean reset  {{int:hue-ixn-classname-ES}}">
<ol class="hue clean reset  {{int:hue-ixn-classname-ES}}">


{{li|start=y|I=S2/IV|Q=618|Q2=618}}
{{li|start=y|I=Z1/DX|Q=618|Q2=618}}Gerry Healy  ->  I'm putting him in strawberry because he allied with Gorbachev. could be seen as overly generous when the Soviet government was outright blue in 1990. but he did ally with the ICFI before that, so, like, despite doing things that are arguably more horrible than Stalin did — Stalin always had halfway plausible excuses of 'defending the Third World', Healy did not — his abilities as a theorist are somewhere in between Gorbachev and Stalin.
 
{{li|I=Z1/ML|Q=618|Q2=618}}Workers Revolutionary Party


</li></ol> -->
</li></ol>


== Subjective themes (no AI) ==
== Subjective themes (no AI) ==
<!--
<ol class="hue clean reset  {{int:hue-ixn-classname-ES}}">
<ol class="hue clean reset  {{int:hue-ixn-classname-ES}}">
</li></ol> -->
 
{{li|start=y|I=S2/MX|Q=618|Q2=618}}Healy rejected meta-Marxism / Gerry Healy rejected [[E:Meta-Marxism is a concept and not a person|meta-Marxism]] in approximately 1985; his insistence on solving problems locally in the WRP instead of letting the ICFI in amounts to a refusal to integrate the lessons of other apparently-Marxist groups in order to come to a materially-accurate characterization of [[E:objectivity (meta-Marxism)|both factions]]
 
{{li|I=S1/DX|Q=618|Q2=618}}Gerry Healy sex abuse scandal [https://www.wsws.org/en/special/library/healy/10.html]  ->  ah. out of all the reasons to reject an investigation into the workings of your party that sure is one of them.
 
{{li|I=F2/ML|Q=618|Q2=618}}Healy allied himself to Gorbachev because of the shock of the WRP collapsing; this is to imply he was not already in nearly the same position as the Soviet bureaucracy right before the collapse of the party [https://www.wsws.org/en/special/library/healy/10.html]
 
{{li|I=S2/IV|Q=618|Q2=618}}Healy increasingly attributed the advances of the World Party not to the Marxist principles of the Fourth International ... but rather to his own personal abilities [https://www.wsws.org/en/special/library/healy/10.html]
 
</li></ol>


== Usage notes ==
== Usage notes ==
Line 36: Line 51:
{{li|start=y
{{li|start=y
     |I=S1/IV|Q=46,99|Q2=4699}}{{TTS|IV|Trotskyism}} / [[EC:9k/RD/Q4699|Socialism AI]]
     |I=S1/IV|Q=46,99|Q2=4699}}{{TTS|IV|Trotskyism}} / [[EC:9k/RD/Q4699|Socialism AI]]
{{li|I=S1/IV|Q=41,04|Q2=4104}}{{TTS|IV|Fourth}} / Trotskyism
{{li|I=Z1/MX|Q=83|Q2=83}}{{TTS|MN|Marxism}} / [[EC:9k/RD/Q83|dialectical materialism]]
{{li|I=Z1/MX|Q=83|Q2=83}}{{TTS|MN|Marxism}} / [[EC:9k/RD/Q83|dialectical materialism]]
{{li|I=S1/IV|Q=41,04|Q2=4104}}{{TTS|IV|Fourth}} / Trotskyism
{{li|I=Z0/MX/ML|Q=90|Q2=90}}{{TTS|MX|meta-Marxism}} / [[EC:9k/RD/Q90|apparent forms of Marxism]]
{{li|I=Z0/MX/ML|Q=90|Q2=90}}{{TTS|MX|meta-Marxism}} / [[EC:9k/RD/Q90|apparent forms of Marxism]]
{{li|I=S1/ML|Q=618  |Q2=618}}{{TTS|ML|M-L}}  / arguments defending Stalin
{{li|I=S1/ML|Q=23,52|Q2=2352}}{{TTS|ML|M-L}}  / crimson counterrevolutions
{{li|I=S1/DX|Q=23,52|Q2=2352}}{{TTS|DX|D.X.}} / strawberry counterrevolutions
{{li|I=S1/DX|Q=23,53|Q2=2353}}{{TTS|DX|D.X.}} / bureaucratic theoretical tendencies
{{li|I=S1/DX|Q=618|Q2=618}}{{TTS|DX|D.X.}} / bureaucratic abuses (Soviet Union)
</li></ol>
</li></ol>




[[Category:"Trans4mer" pages (RD)]] [[Category:Nickel links (NickelBank)]]  <!-- page ends here. TTS-unfriendly strings incoming
[[Category:"Trans4mer" pages (RD)]]  <!-- page ends here. TTS-unfriendly strings incoming
redirects or titles:  [[Ontology talk:9k/RD/Q618-TheJamesPCannonOfBritain/x01]]
redirects or titles:  [[Ontology talk:9k/RD/Q618-TheJamesPCannonOfBritain/x01]]
thread ID (for search purposes):  3c83e84d-8e68-428b-a810-84e2dcb27739
thread ID (for search purposes):  3c83e84d-8e68-428b-a810-84e2dcb27739
duplication hint:  copy markup from [[Special:PermanentLink/NNNNN|trans4mer page]] -->
duplication hint:  copy markup from [[Special:PermanentLink/NNNNN|trans4mer page]] -->

Latest revision as of 07:59, 22 August 2026

Prompt

Was there anyone close to being a counterpart of James P. Cannon in Britain, in terms of their level of knowledge on Marxist analysis and their political positions?

Motifs or claims

  1. James P. Cannon / Jim Cannon (Healy) [1]
  2. the James Cannon of Britain / the James P. Cannon of Britain / [... prompt] (question)

Response

  1. Gerry Healy -> I'm putting him in strawberry because he allied with Gorbachev. could be seen as overly generous when the Soviet government was outright blue in 1990. but he did ally with the ICFI before that, so, like, despite doing things that are arguably more horrible than Stalin did — Stalin always had halfway plausible excuses of 'defending the Third World', Healy did not — his abilities as a theorist are somewhere in between Gorbachev and Stalin.
  2. Workers Revolutionary Party

Subjective themes (no AI)

  1. Healy rejected meta-Marxism / Gerry Healy rejected meta-Marxism in approximately 1985; his insistence on solving problems locally in the WRP instead of letting the ICFI in amounts to a refusal to integrate the lessons of other apparently-Marxist groups in order to come to a materially-accurate characterization of both factions
  2. Gerry Healy sex abuse scandal [2] -> ah. out of all the reasons to reject an investigation into the workings of your party that sure is one of them.
  3. Healy allied himself to Gorbachev because of the shock of the WRP collapsing; this is to imply he was not already in nearly the same position as the Soviet bureaucracy right before the collapse of the party [3]
  4. Healy increasingly attributed the advances of the World Party not to the Marxist principles of the Fourth International ... but rather to his own personal abilities [4]

Usage notes

  • You are allowed to post LLM prompts as prototype pages (the part you wrote manually), as long as they stay in one of the pronounced Talk namespaces and there are no direct quotes from machine-generated text. Concisely describing abstract propositions that turn up several times inside response text is fine.
  • It's recommended you include all of the AI's "references", such that each prompt becomes a sort of 'combination nickel' that becomes a convenient place for collecting twenty or so links that answer the question. If any of the pages referenced are already nickel pages, you should link the nickel page.

Links

Ideologies, fields, topics, or search engines

  1. pronounced Trotskyism / Socialism AI
  2. pronounced Fourth / Trotskyism
  3. pronounced Marxism / dialectical materialism
  4. pronounced meta-Marxism / apparent forms of Marxism
  5. pronounced M-L / arguments defending Stalin
  6. pronounced M-L / crimson counterrevolutions
  7. pronounced D.X. / strawberry counterrevolutions
  8. pronounced D.X. / bureaucratic theoretical tendencies
  9. pronounced D.X. / bureaucratic abuses (Soviet Union)
Retrieved from "https://research.moraleconomy.au/index.php?title=Ontology_talk:9k/RD/Q618-TheJamesPCannonOfBritain/x01&oldid=45444"