Jump to content

Ontology talk:9k/RD/Q31,04: Difference between revisions

From LithoGraphica
Reversedragon (talk | contribs)
m numbers
Reversedragon (talk | contribs)
Is there any actual difference between general-sense agorism and general-sense postmodernism?
 
(5 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{NextNineThousand|PPPA=agorists waking up|E=Q618|User=RD|Contents=y}}
{{NextNineThousand|PPPA=agorists waking up|E=Q31,04|User=RD|Contents=y}}
== Main entry ==
== Main entry ==
{{HueCSS/v1}}<ol class="hue clean  {{int:hue-ixn-classname-DFy}}"><!-- inactive: {{int:hue-ixn-classname-ML}} -->
{{HueCSS/v1}}<ol class="hue clean  {{int:hue-ixn-classname-DFy}}"><!-- inactive: {{int:hue-ixn-classname-ML}} -->
Line 9: Line 9:
</li></ol>
</li></ol>


== Related ==
== Dungeons & Dragons ==
<ol class="hue clean  {{int:hue-ixn-classname-DFy}}">
 
{{li|start=y|I=S1/ES|tradition=|Q=63,06|Q2=6306}}make as much D&D as possible (Hasbro) {{YouTube|aeQOVk-FDPI}} {{YouTube|x0S3sqKTjPo}} / D&D [[E:paperclip AI (thought experiment)|paperclip machine]] (motif) {{YouTube|x0S3sqKTjPo|rem=Why did D&D 5.5e (2024) fail? (Rules Lawyer)}}
 
{{li|I=S1/ES|tradition=|Q=618|Q2=618}}the 3rd-party publishers who had been crucial to helping D&D become dominant  ->  I think it's important to stop and think about this for a bit. D&D's core writers had two kinds of allies early on: arbitrary individuals making homebrew rules like the Illusionist boy, and actual third-party companies. by 2024 events like this have shown that those two categories of people
 
{{li|I=S1/ES|tradition=|Q=63,03|Q2=6303}}the aggregate can do infinite products / you can do one product per month; the aggregate can do infinite products per month {{YouTube|aeQOVk-FDPI}}  ->  {{TTS|tts=r/AccidentallyCommunist|r/accidentallycommunist}}
 
{{li|I=S1/Fy/IV|tradition=|Q=618|Q2=618}}world where cluster of soviets made D&D fifth editions  ->  this sounds vacuous at first like it doesn't really mean anything, but when you look into the actual sequence of events of Hasbro trying hard to make new editions just to make money, it actually gets weirdly interesting. think about the idea of workers at Hasbro racking their brains about how to make a new edition that's worth buying, just like is happening now. it would turn into more of a debate than an active clash against different islands of people. I wonder what it would actually look like. there are so many potential Ironblood episodes hiding in all the pointless videos about some past year's corporate sales and decisions<br/>
see, this is why I can't play Dungeons & Dragons.... for some reason what my brain {{em|really}} wants to roleplay is people actually finding a sensible way to produce the game
 
</li></ol>
 
== Consciousness ==
<ol class="hue clean  {{int:hue-ixn-classname-DFy}}">
<ol class="hue clean  {{int:hue-ixn-classname-DFy}}">


{{li|start=y|I=S1/IV|tradition=IV oer MX, MX onto MX|Q=45,03|Q2=4503}}meta-framework as construct  ->  so. while developing meta-Marxist non-binary logic I constructed this concept of the "meta-analysis framework" ({{TTS|html=code|tts=framework X onto Y|__ onto __}}, {{TTS|html=code|tts=X through Y|__ thru __}}, or {{TTS|html=code|tts=X o'er Y|__ oer __}}). and it's a very peculiar thing. it doesn't really guarantee that the people using it are truly gaining insight into reality {{em|just because they have one}}. even I knew that, but now of course it's a lot more glaring the more I get into Trotskyism. still... I feel like, just descriptively, building meta-frameworks to feel like they understand things is still a thing people keep trying to do, and it's useful to write that down and represent that. I guess I'm getting dangerously close to building "meta-meta-Marxism" right now; I've gotta be careful to not actually go there because that would be genuine insanity. (post-postmodernist 'metamodern' art, I'm looking at you.)<br/>
{{li|start=y|I=S1/IV|tradition=IV oer MX, MX onto MX|Q=45,03|Q2=4503}}meta-framework as construct  ->  so. while developing meta-Marxist non-binary logic I constructed this concept of the "meta-analysis framework" ({{TTS|html=code|tts=framework X onto Y|__ onto __}}, {{TTS|html=code|tts=X through Y|__ thru __}}, or {{TTS|html=code|tts=X o'er Y|__ oer __}}). and it's a very peculiar thing. it doesn't really guarantee that the people using it are truly gaining insight into reality {{em|just because they have one}}. even I knew that, but now of course it's a lot more glaring the more I get into Trotskyism. still... I feel like, just descriptively, building meta-frameworks to feel like they understand things is still a thing people keep trying to do, and it's useful to write that down and represent that. I guess I'm getting dangerously close to building "meta-meta-Marxism" right now; I've gotta be careful to not actually go there because that would be genuine insanity. (post-postmodernist 'metamodern' art, I'm looking at you.)<br/>
but, okay. follow me here. "agorists waking up" is an instance of a potentially faulty meta-analysis framework being applied to a real problem as people become half-conscious that there is a problem. I think it's worth stopping and thinking about that. about how many faulty meta-analysis frameworks there might be, from Western-Marxism to anarchism to Stalinist Materialism to accidental postmodernism by Tony Cliff to any number of things. and 'pure' [[E:Q92|violet Marxism]], but I already got "Stalinist Materialism" in there so all the prototypical violet errors would already be in that.
but, okay. follow me here. "agorists waking up" is an instance of a potentially faulty meta-analysis framework being applied to a real problem as people become half-conscious that there is a problem. I think it's worth stopping and thinking about that. about how many faulty meta-analysis frameworks there might be, from Western-Marxism to anarchism to Stalinist Materialism to accidental postmodernism by Tony Cliff to any number of things. and 'pure' [[E:Q92|violet Marxism]], but I already got "Stalinist Materialism" in there so all the prototypical violet errors would already be in that.
</li></ol>
== Related ==
<ol class="hue clean  {{int:hue-ixn-classname-DFy}}">
{{li|start=y|I=S1/A/MX|tradition=MX onto A|Q=54,14|Q2=5414}}benign and malignant anarchisms / classifying anarchisms like tumors / classifying communities (populations; civilizations) like tumors  ->  the idea here isn't actually to assert that anarchisms are inherently bad (despite how Marx, Engels, and Lenin would have their suspicions anarchism can never rise above bourgeois ideology). the concept of this Item is just that there are some groups of anarchists that could be benign, hypothetically speaking, and some groups of anarchists that are not in that category and instead undergo a process where they start 'dividing out of control' — where no stated control mechanism within the anarchism can actually stop them from turning back into market processes consisting of capitalist territories, into capitalism, into Liberal-republican parties, and into a Liberal-republican state similar to the United States federal government.<br/>
the concept that all anarchisms are malignant anarchisms is a separate proposition from this.
{{li|I=S1/MX/A/ES|tradition=MX onto ES, MX onto ES thru A|Q=54,13|Q2=5413}}malignant anarchism  ->  the motif of a philosophy which on the surface fits the image of an anarchism but undergoes a "malignancy process" in which it converts fully into capitalism and Liberal-republicanism.<br/>
there. I have taken one of the core concepts of anarchism ("societies become hierarchies because bad Ideals") and actually made it intelligent. now anarchists have to reckon with the concept there are actual material processes for malignancy where a bunch of smaller things all function in parallel and that you need more than Ideas or Community (their other favorite thing) to have any hope of stopping.
{{li|I=S2/MX/ES|tradition=|Q=618|Q2=618}}Modernism (modernity; modern period; physical modernism object) is when there are large corporations and the world isn't filled with tiny businesses; this is to imply that state businesses and private businesses are the exact same thing whenever they get large enough and there is genuinely no difference between them; this is to imply there is no meaningful difference between Liberal-republicanism, Stalinism, and Dengism although there are surface differences  ->  every time I hear something that even {{em|sounds like}} postmodernism (postmodernism proper, Tony Cliff, the Toynbee tiles man, some {{film|MLP:FiM}} episodes about Starlight or the Friendship School) all I can ever get out of any of it is this. it seems like at the heart of postmodernism there is almost literally nothing more to it than this. everything else is empty fluff trying to put up a bunch of floaty Idealist ladders to support {{em|this}} central claim that most of them can't even concretely describe.
{{li|I=M3/ES|tradition=MX onto ES|Q=618|Q2=618}}Is there any actual difference between general-sense agorism and general-sense postmodernism?  ->  we're going for the broadest reasonable definitions here. general-sense postmodernism encompasses almost anything that revolves around "rejecting all grand narratives" and still sounds highly similar to postmodernism-proper. general-sense agorism (a.k.a. "capital-E Existentialism") encompasses anything that involves the same core theme cluster of "modeling society based on individual relationships", "don't like don't read", "all dissimilar oppressions are in fact the same thing", and "liberating the totality of non-aggressive activities" (there might be a couple more things).<br/>
honestly, what I think right now is when you strip away all the statements in postmodernism that flat-out don't mean anything it becomes indistinguishable from general-sense agorism. what I think right now is that postmodernism is Actually Just Agorism but worse and less clear.


</li></ol>
</li></ol>
Line 19: Line 49:
== {{int:hue-prototype-trads-topics-or-genres}} ==
== {{int:hue-prototype-trads-topics-or-genres}} ==
<ol class="hue clean terse  {{int:hue-ixn-classname-DFy}}">
<ol class="hue clean terse  {{int:hue-ixn-classname-DFy}}">
{{li|start=y
    |I=S1/ES/Ag|Q=53,42|Q2=5342}}[[EC:9k/RD/Q53,42|agorism]]
<!--
<!--
{{li|start=y
{{li|I=S1/MX|Q=92|Q2=92}}{{TTS|MX|M.X.}} / meta-Marxism
    |I=S1/MX|Q=92|Q2=92}}{{TTS|MX|M.X.}} / meta-Marxism
{{li|I=Z1/IV|Q=41,04|Q2=4104}}{{TTS|IV|Fourth}} / Trotskyism -->
{{li|I=Z1/IV|Q=41,04|Q2=4104}}{{TTS|IV|Fourth}} / Trotskyism -->
</li></ol>
</li></ol>

Latest revision as of 05:55, 21 November 2026

Main entry

  1. agorists waking up -> the motif of people who exist day to day within an online agora (or on-the-ground conventions that function similarly) that they conceptualize as a "community" suddenly realizing that they are in fact in an agora and becoming repulsed by the observation that all the interaction and social activity in the agora is being converted into small production that neatly resembles small capitalism whether it contains sales and profits or not. this is always glorious to see if you ask me. although, most of the time people do it they never actually go anywhere interesting from there.
  2. agorists waking up / you're suddenly in a rat race that echoes what you come to these spaces to try to avoid or escape from [1]

Dungeons & Dragons

  1. make as much D&D as possible (Hasbro) [2] [3] / D&D paperclip machine (motif) [4]
  2. the 3rd-party publishers who had been crucial to helping D&D become dominant -> I think it's important to stop and think about this for a bit. D&D's core writers had two kinds of allies early on: arbitrary individuals making homebrew rules like the Illusionist boy, and actual third-party companies. by 2024 events like this have shown that those two categories of people
  3. the aggregate can do infinite products / you can do one product per month; the aggregate can do infinite products per month [5] -> pronounced r/AccidentallyCommunist
  4. world where cluster of soviets made D&D fifth editions -> this sounds vacuous at first like it doesn't really mean anything, but when you look into the actual sequence of events of Hasbro trying hard to make new editions just to make money, it actually gets weirdly interesting. think about the idea of workers at Hasbro racking their brains about how to make a new edition that's worth buying, just like is happening now. it would turn into more of a debate than an active clash against different islands of people. I wonder what it would actually look like. there are so many potential Ironblood episodes hiding in all the pointless videos about some past year's corporate sales and decisions
    see, this is why I can't play Dungeons & Dragons.... for some reason what my brain really wants to roleplay is people actually finding a sensible way to produce the game

Consciousness

  1. meta-framework as construct -> so. while developing meta-Marxist non-binary logic I constructed this concept of the "meta-analysis framework" (pronounced framework X onto Y, pronounced X through Y, or pronounced X o'er Y). and it's a very peculiar thing. it doesn't really guarantee that the people using it are truly gaining insight into reality just because they have one. even I knew that, but now of course it's a lot more glaring the more I get into Trotskyism. still... I feel like, just descriptively, building meta-frameworks to feel like they understand things is still a thing people keep trying to do, and it's useful to write that down and represent that. I guess I'm getting dangerously close to building "meta-meta-Marxism" right now; I've gotta be careful to not actually go there because that would be genuine insanity. (post-postmodernist 'metamodern' art, I'm looking at you.)
    but, okay. follow me here. "agorists waking up" is an instance of a potentially faulty meta-analysis framework being applied to a real problem as people become half-conscious that there is a problem. I think it's worth stopping and thinking about that. about how many faulty meta-analysis frameworks there might be, from Western-Marxism to anarchism to Stalinist Materialism to accidental postmodernism by Tony Cliff to any number of things. and 'pure' violet Marxism, but I already got "Stalinist Materialism" in there so all the prototypical violet errors would already be in that.

Related

  1. benign and malignant anarchisms / classifying anarchisms like tumors / classifying communities (populations; civilizations) like tumors -> the idea here isn't actually to assert that anarchisms are inherently bad (despite how Marx, Engels, and Lenin would have their suspicions anarchism can never rise above bourgeois ideology). the concept of this Item is just that there are some groups of anarchists that could be benign, hypothetically speaking, and some groups of anarchists that are not in that category and instead undergo a process where they start 'dividing out of control' — where no stated control mechanism within the anarchism can actually stop them from turning back into market processes consisting of capitalist territories, into capitalism, into Liberal-republican parties, and into a Liberal-republican state similar to the United States federal government.
    the concept that all anarchisms are malignant anarchisms is a separate proposition from this.
  2. malignant anarchism -> the motif of a philosophy which on the surface fits the image of an anarchism but undergoes a "malignancy process" in which it converts fully into capitalism and Liberal-republicanism.
    there. I have taken one of the core concepts of anarchism ("societies become hierarchies because bad Ideals") and actually made it intelligent. now anarchists have to reckon with the concept there are actual material processes for malignancy where a bunch of smaller things all function in parallel and that you need more than Ideas or Community (their other favorite thing) to have any hope of stopping.
  3. Modernism (modernity; modern period; physical modernism object) is when there are large corporations and the world isn't filled with tiny businesses; this is to imply that state businesses and private businesses are the exact same thing whenever they get large enough and there is genuinely no difference between them; this is to imply there is no meaningful difference between Liberal-republicanism, Stalinism, and Dengism although there are surface differences -> every time I hear something that even sounds like postmodernism (postmodernism proper, Tony Cliff, the Toynbee tiles man, some MLP:FiM episodes about Starlight or the Friendship School) all I can ever get out of any of it is this. it seems like at the heart of postmodernism there is almost literally nothing more to it than this. everything else is empty fluff trying to put up a bunch of floaty Idealist ladders to support this central claim that most of them can't even concretely describe.
  4. Is there any actual difference between general-sense agorism and general-sense postmodernism? -> we're going for the broadest reasonable definitions here. general-sense postmodernism encompasses almost anything that revolves around "rejecting all grand narratives" and still sounds highly similar to postmodernism-proper. general-sense agorism (a.k.a. "capital-E Existentialism") encompasses anything that involves the same core theme cluster of "modeling society based on individual relationships", "don't like don't read", "all dissimilar oppressions are in fact the same thing", and "liberating the totality of non-aggressive activities" (there might be a couple more things).
    honestly, what I think right now is when you strip away all the statements in postmodernism that flat-out don't mean anything it becomes indistinguishable from general-sense agorism. what I think right now is that postmodernism is Actually Just Agorism but worse and less clear.

Ideologies, topics, or genres

  1. agorism

Wavebuilder combinations

Subpages or related scraps