Philosophical Research:RatingHub/YT/MarxMindset: Difference between revisions
Additional remarks |
m motif: to overcome the whole nation of owners on the layer above them they must be arranged into a whole nation of workers ... |
||
| Line 4: | Line 4: | ||
* This channel ostensibly contains talks on Marxism. | * This channel ostensibly contains talks on Marxism. | ||
* This channel's scripts are AI-generated. This rating sheet can be used as an assessment of the quality of the | * This channel's scripts are AI-generated. This rating sheet can be used as an assessment of the quality of the {{abbr|title=large language model|LLM}}. | ||
* This channel's content is approximately popular-level. | * This channel's content is approximately popular-level. | ||
| Line 22: | Line 22: | ||
{{WorkRating| The Most Dangerous Thing You Can Own Is Awareness (video 118) |G={{U}}|RR=6767|Q=0| -- }} | {{WorkRating| The Most Dangerous Thing You Can Own Is Awareness (video 118) |G={{U}}|RR=6767|Q=0| -- }} | ||
{{WorkRating| Why the System Wants You Silent — And How Your Voice Can Break It (video 117) |G={{U}}|RR=6767|Q=0| -- }}--> | {{WorkRating| Why the System Wants You Silent — And How Your Voice Can Break It (video 117) |G={{U}}|RR=6767|Q=0| -- }}--> | ||
{{WorkRating| Never Meant to Be Grateful for Survival <ref name="grateful"/> (video 116) |G={{G|field_ML}}|RR=6767|Q= | {{WorkRating| Never Meant to Be Grateful for Survival <ref name="grateful"/> (video 116) |G={{G|field_ML}}|RR=6767|Q=1| {{E:P206/G}} }} | ||
<!--{{WorkRating| The System Only Changes When People Stop Enduring (video 115) |G={{U}}|RR=6767|Q=0| -- }} | <!--{{WorkRating| The System Only Changes When People Stop Enduring (video 115) |G={{U}}|RR=6767|Q=0| -- }} | ||
{{WorkRating| Why Resistance Always Begins as Discomfort (video 114) |G={{U}}|RR=6767|Q=0| -- }} | {{WorkRating| Why Resistance Always Begins as Discomfort (video 114) |G={{U}}|RR=6767|Q=0| -- }} | ||
| Line 143: | Line 143: | ||
<!-- {{HueCSS}} <ol class="hue clean"> | <!-- {{HueCSS}} <ol class="hue clean"> | ||
</li></ol>--> | </li></ol>--> | ||
=== Subjective motifs === | |||
{{HueCSS}} <ol class="hue clean"> | |||
<li class="field_mdem" data-tradition="MX onto ML" value="618" data-dimension="S2">To free the proletariat from the draining grasp of the bourgeoisie, it is not enough for people to be arranged into a mass of workers; to overcome the whole nation of owners on the layer above them they must be arranged into a whole nation of workers that can be said to have created the overall nation, while in many populations the structural foundation of the population is in constant flux and this is not true yet <ref name="grateful"/> | |||
</li></ol> | |||
== Additional remarks == | == Additional remarks == | ||
| Line 152: | Line 159: | ||
* "To perceive exploitation as a few greedy individuals..." — it's a little depressing how this AI actually understands Marxism better than some [[E:Western Marxism|Western-Marxists]].<ref name="grateful"/> | * "To perceive exploitation as a few greedy individuals..." — it's a little depressing how this AI actually understands Marxism better than some [[E:Western Marxism|Western-Marxists]].<ref name="grateful"/> | ||
== | == Videos == | ||
<references> | <references> | ||
Latest revision as of 12:25, 21 January 2026
Background
Rating subject: YouTube video channel @MarxMindset
- This channel ostensibly contains talks on Marxism.
- This channel's scripts are AI-generated. This rating sheet can be used as an assessment of the quality of the LLM.
- This channel's content is approximately popular-level.
- approximate number of entries
- 119
Rating sheet[edit]
Motifs[edit]
Subjective motifs[edit]
- To free the proletariat from the draining grasp of the bourgeoisie, it is not enough for people to be arranged into a mass of workers; to overcome the whole nation of owners on the layer above them they must be arranged into a whole nation of workers that can be said to have created the overall nation, while in many populations the structural foundation of the population is in constant flux and this is not true yet [1]
Additional remarks[edit]
- The titles on this channel have a strange focus on "you", "time", and "consciousness" or "conditioning". This vaguely suggests the AI has been reading a lot of Western-Marxism or blue anarchism.[1]
- However, the titles seem to contrast with the actual content of the videos, which focus a lot more on material relationships above the individual.[1]
- "To perceive exploitation as a few greedy individuals..." — it's a little depressing how this AI actually understands Marxism better than some Western-Marxists.[1]