Jump to content

Philosophical Research:RatingHub/YT/MarxMindset: Difference between revisions

From Philosophical Research
m hide senses
Additional remarks
Line 22: Line 22:
{{WorkRating| The Most Dangerous Thing You Can Own Is Awareness (video 118)  |G={{U}}|RR=6767|Q=0| -- }}
{{WorkRating| The Most Dangerous Thing You Can Own Is Awareness (video 118)  |G={{U}}|RR=6767|Q=0| -- }}
{{WorkRating| Why the System Wants You Silent — And How Your Voice Can Break It (video 117)  |G={{U}}|RR=6767|Q=0| -- }}-->
{{WorkRating| Why the System Wants You Silent — And How Your Voice Can Break It (video 117)  |G={{U}}|RR=6767|Q=0| -- }}-->
{{WorkRating| Never Meant to Be Grateful for Survival <ref name="grateful"/> (video 116)  |G={{U}}|RR=6767|Q=0| -- }} <!-- {{E:P206/G}} -->
{{WorkRating| Never Meant to Be Grateful for Survival <ref name="grateful"/> (video 116)  |G={{G|field_ML}}|RR=6767|Q=0| -- }} <!-- {{E:P206/G}} -->
<!--{{WorkRating| The System Only Changes When People Stop Enduring (video 115)  |G={{U}}|RR=6767|Q=0| -- }}
<!--{{WorkRating| The System Only Changes When People Stop Enduring (video 115)  |G={{U}}|RR=6767|Q=0| -- }}
{{WorkRating| Why Resistance Always Begins as Discomfort (video 114)  |G={{U}}|RR=6767|Q=0| -- }}
{{WorkRating| Why Resistance Always Begins as Discomfort (video 114)  |G={{U}}|RR=6767|Q=0| -- }}
Line 137: Line 137:
{{WorkRating| Break the Chains: How You Become Unstoppable When You Understand Your True Worth (video 3)  |G={{U}}|RR=6767|Q=0| -- }}
{{WorkRating| Break the Chains: How You Become Unstoppable When You Understand Your True Worth (video 3)  |G={{U}}|RR=6767|Q=0| -- }}
{{WorkRating| The Degree of Exploitation of Labour Power (video 2)  |G={{U}}|RR=6767|Q=0| -- }}
{{WorkRating| The Degree of Exploitation of Labour Power (video 2)  |G={{U}}|RR=6767|Q=0| -- }}
{{WorkRating| The Two Fold Charactor of the Labour Embodied in Commodities (video 1)  |G={{U}}|RR=6767|Q=0| -- }}-->
{{WorkRating| The Two Fold Character of the Labour Embodied in Commodities (video 1)  |G={{U}}|RR=6767|Q=0| -- }}-->
</dl>
</dl>


Line 148: Line 148:
== Additional remarks ==
== Additional remarks ==


* (none)
* The titles on this channel have a strange focus on "you", "time", and "consciousness" or "conditioning". This vaguely suggests the AI has been reading a lot of [[E:Western Marxism|Western-Marxism]] or [[:Category:Existentialist-Structuralist tradition ontology|blue anarchism]].<ref name="grateful"/>
** However, the titles seem to contrast with the actual content of the videos, which focus a lot more on material relationships above the individual.<ref name="grateful"/>
* "To perceive exploitation as a few greedy individuals..." ­— it's a little depressing how this AI actually understands Marxism better than some [[E:Western Marxism|Western-Marxists]].<ref name="grateful"/>


== References ==
== References ==

Revision as of 13:18, 19 January 2026

Background

Rating subject: YouTube video channel @MarxMindset

  • This channel ostensibly contains talks on Marxism.
  • This channel's scripts are AI-generated. This rating sheet can be used as an assessment of the quality of the AI.
  • This channel's content is approximately popular-level.
field, scope, or group [Item]
early Marxism (proposed; ML)1-1-1
theorists mentioned
pronounced 49,01. (Z) pronounced (ML) (Z): Marx (CC)1-1-1 [1]
approximate number of entries
119
overall rating
U / Unknown1-1-1

Rating sheet

contained work
Never Meant to Be Grateful for Survival [1] (video 116)
rating
G / Good1-1-1
tests
--
0

Motifs

Additional remarks

  • The titles on this channel have a strange focus on "you", "time", and "consciousness" or "conditioning". This vaguely suggests the AI has been reading a lot of Western-Marxism or blue anarchism.[1]
    • However, the titles seem to contrast with the actual content of the videos, which focus a lot more on material relationships above the individual.[1]
  • "To perceive exploitation as a few greedy individuals..." ­— it's a little depressing how this AI actually understands Marxism better than some Western-Marxists.[1]

References

  1. 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 Never Meant to Be Grateful for Survival [1]