Jump to content

Ontology:P204

From Philosophical Research
Revision as of 11:27, 17 May 2025 by Reversedragon (talk | contribs) (copy prototype notes from RatingHub)
  1. "Trotsky test"
"Trotsky test"
field value

Characteristics in draft

Properties

item type
P
aliases (en)
communication question 04: "Trotsky test"
QID references
P200 rating / communication rating level
color swatch references
--
Property data type
item
instance of
communication rating level

Prototype notes

  • Would this description or argument be inherently objectionable to Leon Trotsky?
    • This question usually does not apply if the work is a Trotskyist work, although there could be small exceptions for a version of Trotskyism that Trotsky had huge problems with.
    • This test is definitely going to surprise some people with when it pops up. It could pop up when Stalin is talking about protecting consensuses. It could pop up when someone casually spouts a statement of anticommunism and then goes on and on about some weird Existentialist model of Free Will. If that's the only good thing about him, Trotsky would not let that stand.