9k:RD/ terrible things happen to Russians (Q76,68)
Appearance
Content warnings
- Page title is accurate to what it contains.
- Dead dove; do not eat.
Main entry
- thought experiment in which terrible things happen to Russians -> I just keep collecting these. there is something to be said for scenarios where you can demonstrate disturbing things happening after some particular causal factor is put in but where the thought experiment itself isn't considered unspeakably offensive.
Bad things happening to Russians
- Would you kill a Russian in order to vote? / Would you kill a Russian to receive your voter card? -> you live in an alternate world where every individual in the United States is entitled to a voting license the day they kill a Russian. policies are mostly the same. voting brings anti-discrimination laws, healthcare programs, whatever. but you have to kill someone in Eurasia to get to vote, or to get to tell anyone else to vote. want people to vote for gun control? every one of them has to fly over and shoot a Russian, and then you can have it. the central question of this thought experiment is this: how much is voting worth? what lengths is it worth going to just to preserve voting and the "normal" process of getting people to vote? would people chant "vote Democrat" as loudly if every one of them was required to kill a Russian? what about if voting Democrat really does take a little power away from Tories to create more structural racism and kill Black people? should everyone go kill a Russian just to save Black people from fascism? or is preserving the life of Russians more important than that aim? the only thing about this metaphor that's incoherent to me is how you prove anyone actually killed anyone. uh. maybe there are a limited number of voter licenses, and you'd just take one from Russia and hold it up. or maybe everyone has an ID card which clearly has a flag on it and you'd take that. there may or may not be a system where any country can kill people to issue voter licenses but just as in real life most countries are too afraid to attack the United States. also you equally get a point if you kill a United States Communist and it can be proven in court, even though they deliberately don't have different id card flags. in this world people go to court to prove they have done approved heinous things as well as to prove they're innocent.
- Would a Russia made of reactionaries deserve sovereignty? (composed of reactionaries; consisting only or solely of conservative bigots) / If every Russian is reactionary, do they deserve a government? / If every Russian was a reactionary, would it be acceptable for people in another country to assist in a plan to gut Russia of its government, install leaders chosen to interface well with the United States or Europe, and turn it into a client state? (Russia, China, Korea, Vietnam, Cuba, Iraq, Iran, etc; insert Third World nationality which has been "assigned conservative at birth"; insert country which has literally undergone this) -> this is a question to catch anarchist and center-Liberal Idealists that think they're "postcolonial" but by any reasonable Materialist definition are passively committing exocolonialism and are actually colonial. only if you say "no" can you genuinely have a postcolonial theory. if you say "yes", you can be an anarchist, Trotskyist, or Existentialist, but you are an imperialist. it is true that anyone who answers "no" to this question has a new contradiction to answer in what it's acceptable to do to a misbehaving country other than war or client state, but this is still a critical question that separates Marxism from Liberal-republicanism.
Nazi Germany is a very special edge case which I will arbitrarily say is not part of this question because it's so difficult; it's a little hard to say what other than war is even possible there. I think it's important to have an answer so people don't get cornered back into this Item, but I think it belongs in its own question or proposition. - Post-structuralism allows the United States to refuse to recognize Russia / Post-structuralist analysis enables United States people to refuse to recognize the entire country of Russia and its government and declare all Russians Americans without questioning any definition of "the United States", "United States people", or "White people" / (9k) ->
... linguistics is not a field that's bound by ethics, anyone can just go around using it unprofessionally. so I'd think that having a sound theory without glitches in it is actually much more important rather than less important.
there has to be something wrong here but I have no idea what it is. - Russians are an idea / Russians are not an idea (exact inverse; sense) / (9k)
- Russians are shovels before dreams / Russians are physical objects, not ideas / Russians are not an abstract concept ... / (9k) -> really have to push back on Mr. Jiang's
when he talks about Russia. he first said that Hegel's dialectic is Fukuyama's dialectic, which is questionable ... he reads Hegel through classical Menshevism, and he appears to believe that a dialectic is when two things contain Ideals and qualities and they fight each other to the death and then the victor appropriates all the loser's Ideals adapting them and distorting them to itself. ... he claims that the Ideas that lose are "extreme" and the ones that win are "the middle" which is a totally extraneous addition which doesn't explain anything [...].
if dialectics really were Ideas fighting in a cage match they would continue to be Ideas fighting in a cage match when Materialism is introduced to the dialectic. but the physical thing is Russians; if Russia makes its Ideas stronger it must do it by making Russians stronger. so the end conclusion is ... that a physical person who is Russian is an idea. but that can't be true because that doesn't make any sense. you can kill a Russian. you can't physically kill an idea. ... you can nearly never kill an idea once it's actually started to make changes in the world; no matter how much people hate it everyone will always continue knowing about it. ... if archeologists ever figure out how to read an ancient text the ideas can wholly outlive the ancient kingdoms or villages that generated them. Russians are finite and ideas are not. I am sick of the way Putin is "wasting" them frankly. like, Russians are a finite resource that he thinks he has an infinite amount of, just, give me the finest-grade Russians or I start throwing them away.
why does he treat Russians with such internalized racism about how useful or not useful they all are. forget what he does with Ukrainians, those are just target practice to him ... what I want to know is why he is so harsh on Russians that he wants to send significant fractions of them through the grinder ... one of those things suggests esteem for Russians and one of those things suggests utter contempt. those two things put together don't make any sense. ... what part of Russia is he trying to save? - Russians are a finite resource / (9k)
Good things happening to Russians
- Incorporating the Soviet Union was godly
- Attacking the Soviet Union was ungodly
- The Cold War was a social construct / The opposition of Liberal-republican countries against the Soviet Union was nothing more than a social construct in which Liberal-republican countries made up reasons to hate the 14 nationalities of the Soviet Union for reasons largely unrelated to the class composition of the two countries, and related more to the affinity between the 14 major Soviet ethnic groups and the anomalous, hateful non-affinity between the United States and those ethnic groups / (9k) -> persuade me of this using specifically the Russian Revolution, the Soviet Union, and the Cold War, and I might genuinely consider postcolonial anarchisms. I feel like the difficulty of arguing that verges on impossible, but maybe that's just me. I've made it a little easier by leaving out the requirement that anarchism explains how to defeat the Russian empire or win the Cold War, and only handing you the impossible task of arguing Soviet people and United States racists who to this day can hardly stand the idea of somebody living in another country and being Russian are obligated to be friends. that's what I don't understand. how, when United States people are constantly dismissing the existence of reactionaries in their own country as a totally ignorable non- part of their lives, that anarchisms or postcolonial theories that say every opposition between groups of people is an arbitrary decision each group made are supposed to fix anything.
- The Cold War could be won by anarchism
- The Russian Revolution could be won by anarchism
- The United States and Soviet Union could abolish their borders to join into a single entity -> if this were true the previous three propositions would become easier to argue.
- Before-Communism calendar / calendar that starts at 1900 so the Russian Revolution is year 17 / (9k)
Related
- The human body is more precious than any idea / No idea is precious beyond wounding a human soul (religion) / (9k) -> it would be very interesting to see how this interacts with any of these thought experiments. is there any way anarchists can actually end up believing this and not hating Russians without abandoning everything else they believe?