User:RD/9k/Math can save Trotsky (Q40,59)

Main entry

4059. Q4059/Q40,59

      Math can save Trotsky

      / Mathematics can save Leon Trotsky, because morality never will / No moral argument will ever vindicate Trotskyism, whether it is based on the character of Trotskyist parties as Leninists, based on the justifiability of the Trotskyite conspiracy, or based on the "corrupt" or "tyrannical" character of Stalin's party, because the behavior of Trotskyists is not at all comprehensible based on moral frameworks, and any moral framework Stalin-followers may attempt to come up with will invariably cast early Trotskyism as immoral; however, if Trotskyism is taken to be a strictly amoral force in the world rather than an Evil one, then the behavior of Trotskyism can become comprehensible to everyone outside Trotskyism including Stalin-followers, and there is some possibility that Trotskyism can finally be vindicated or forgiven as the bizarre inanimate force of nature it is as people realize that in the end it did not actually have intentions per se in its collision with other Marxisms much less wilful or malicious intentions to destroy them for its own gain when it could have chosen not to; sheer existential-materialist analysis of separate Marxist parties as a contradiction can solve the problem through descriptive mathematical models of behavior where neither language nor most forms of logic or argumentation could solve it ->
      

      it's conceptually funny imagining somebody trying to argue this in court, but thankfully that's not the way that Marxism rolls and people generally know on some level that Marxism exists in something of an anhierarchic collision of nations and parties that has to work itself out other ways than an arbitrarily thrown-together special argument ground inside bourgeois class rule.

Related

618. Q618/Q618

     Plurality cannot be closed by force

     / (Q14,84, 9k) -> ... you need a way of closing plurality that is descriptive rather than prescriptive, so that closing plurality happens but nobody made it happen or ordered it to happen. because anything else causes plurality to reopen and to get fiercer.

Ideology codes

• (none)