Jump to content

9k:RD/ Alex Bale Pixar theory (Q64,73)

From LithoGraphica
(Redirected from Ontology talk:9k/RD/Q6472)

Main entry

  1. Alex Bale Pixar theory; Pixar blooper theory [1]
  2. Pixar outtake animations / (9k) -> I half forgot about this but it really belongs on this page [Let it Go and Deltarune; Communist Sora; "Stalin Theory" intermission slideshow]. there are a bunch of Pixar blooper shorts which seem to have been made from voice actor outtakes or something like that. and one person came up with a really elaborate stack of lore about them and 'how they could have come to be'. it was fun. but when placed next to the unintended symbolism of Kingdom Hearts and Deltarune... a new picture starts to emerge.
    Pixar outtakes unintentionally depict the process of the workers and non-owning managers who create animated movies being forgotten and erased and replaced with fictional worlds and characters that exist in the product they created, such that even once people become aware of capitalism all depictions of Communist revolution in fiction must be re-framed as the rebellion of fictional characters against the owners, writers, or players of fictional characters. Fictional worlds are an appearance-form that becomes the only way to perceive bodies of workers, while workers become invisible, except through the abstract depiction of "people who live in corporate territories" (Disney realm inhabitants, characters in Pixar outtake animations, etc).

Motifs or claims (Alex Bale's video)

  1. animated movies and animated people lesser than real movies and real people / He [Fantastic Mr. Fox] knows that animated movies and animated people are treated as lesser than real movies and real people
  2. [...] none of these animations are being forced to do anything. [...] they don't have to work on the crew, or do these demeaning easter egg roles. But, what else can they do? They need money to buy food [...]. They've ["Pixar Studios"] got the system rigged so that no one's being forced to do anything, no laws are being broken here, but they aren't really given any better options. [...] But, unlike the real film industry, the actors can't unionize and strike for better rights [sic] because the studios can just create copies of the exact same actor to replace them. [...] it's all to hide the corrupt reality behind the scenes -> media critic makes an "entirely fictional" theory about animated films work. it turns out unintentionally brilliant because it accurately describes the condition of all workers ever who aren't in the most prestigious acting careers through the language of pretending it's talking about celebrity actors who are mistreated by not being treated like celebrity actors
  3. unionize and strike for better rights [sic] (2024) -> note: this is a severely outdated description of what strikes do, appropriate to like, 1890. strikes give you hardly anything most of the time. the goal of a strike is actually to get a bigger workers' movement without getting the organization captured. a lot of times you hardly even get any rights if you actually stop and negotiate. so strikes are very "all or nothing". if you don't go all the way up to about the national scale or so (and if you're in Europe that would be at least 2-3 nations) you basically only receive failure and a burned-out body of workers.
  4. Pixar portrays these toys as happily subservient to the humans who gave them life / servants are furniture (Umineko) / I'm just a Darkner (Deltarune) -> the motif where it all started. it really is just a trope that exists independently of representing reality, but right now it also just happens to be one of the most powerful tropes there is.

Related

  1. superstructural fantasy world / (9k) -> basically what this theory and my further commentary on it are doing is unpacking superstructural fantasy worlds and getting closer to a body of strictly-materially-accurate statements about them — mostly focusing on the ones that exist on the level of the real world, like the MLP show versus the MLP toys versus the structure of Hasbro. some of it can still be superimposed on superstructural fantasy worlds inside fiction though, once it's been set down for the real ones. and then you get amazing theories about unintentional Communist subtext in cartoons.
  2. Houses are cash wads

    / Groups of people (households; corporations; buildings; "communities"; kingdoms; republics) containing a stack of gold are nothing more than a stack of gold that does stuff / human beings as wads of money with legs / reification (mentally converting groups of people into disconnected piles of money) / economics (study of disconnected buildings containing money; generic) / (9k)
  3. joining a Union (Kingdom Hearts) / (9k)

Ideologies, topics, or genres

Wavebuilder combinations

Subpages or related scraps