Philosophical Research:RatingHub/YT/revcomintern: Difference between revisions
copy or update rating sheet from YT/communistsofamerica |
Minneapolis and the coming American revolution |
||
| (One intermediate revision by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{Contents}} | |||
<h2 class="toc-only">Background</h2> | |||
Rating subject: YouTube video channel <strong>[https://invidious.nerdvpn.de/channel/UCtO2zDQt-AhF6SwYbXDdFKA @revcomintern]</strong><!-- | Rating subject: YouTube video channel <strong>[https://invidious.nerdvpn.de/channel/UCtO2zDQt-AhF6SwYbXDdFKA @revcomintern]</strong><!-- | ||
| Line 11: | Line 12: | ||
<!-- * This channel mentions "Ted Grant"<ref name="unk" /> in the context of relevant theorists or sources. --> | <!-- * This channel mentions "Ted Grant"<ref name="unk" /> in the context of relevant theorists or sources. --> | ||
<dl class="wikitable hue"> | <dl class="wikitable hue"> | ||
{{HueRoster|EP=PPPA|lang=en| Revolutionary Communist International }} | {{HueRoster|EP=PPPA|lang=en| Revolutionary Communist International }} | ||
| Line 22: | Line 22: | ||
<dl class="wikitable hue data_rating"> | <dl class="wikitable hue data_rating"> | ||
{{WorkRating| {{YouTube|Z-ZICRekmCE|Lenin and Trotsky - what they really stood for | {{WorkRating| {{YouTube|7FdO671bTjY|Minneapolis and the coming American revolution}} (video ??) |G={{U|field_geo}}|RR=4997|Q=0| -- }} <!-- {{E:P202/G}} --> | ||
{{WorkRating| {{YouTube|1UyhO1hMhrU|Russian Revolution: Triumph or Tragedy}} (11 years ago) |G={{G|field_ML}}|RR=4997|Q=1| {{E:P202/G}} }} <!-- Russian Revolution: Triumph or Tragedy - Alan Woods vs. Orlando Figes --> | |||
{{WorkRating| {{YouTube|qHz_PbKs6Jo|The Relevance of Marxism Today}} (12 years ago) |G={{U}}|RR=4997|Q=0| -- }} | |||
{{WorkRating| {{YouTube|Z-ZICRekmCE|Lenin and Trotsky - what they really stood for}} (12 years ago) |G={{NG|field_trotsky}}|RR=4997|Q=3| {{E:P202/NG}} {{E:P206/G}} {{E:P208/G}} }} <!-- Lenin and Trotsky - what they really stood for - Alan Woods --> | |||
</dl> | </dl> | ||
== Motifs == | == Motifs == | ||
{{HueCSS}}<ol class="hue clean"> | |||
</li><li {{ | </li><li {{IF2/IV/class}} value="618">The ruling class will not attack an idea which is dead <ref name="qhz"/> -> that seems pretty dubious if you've ever seen capitalists try to attack Black civil rights movements as literally Communism. | ||
</li><li {{IS2/ML/class}} value="618">Bolshevism is nonviolent until capitalists attack it <ref name="zz-ce"/> | |||
</li><li {{IS2/ML/class}} value="618">Stalin's Marxism does not create fascism <ref name="uy-u"/> -> well... that's true. it does expose quite a contradiction in Trotskyism though. Trotskyism always goes around saying Stalin and all his followers were dictators. which.... you can see how that would invite accusations that Trotskyists are just as bad. stand with Stalin in your own [[E:Cold War|world class war]], Trotsky, and you wouldn't be in this mess. | |||
</li></ol> | </li></ol> | ||
| Line 38: | Line 43: | ||
<references> | <references> | ||
<ref name="zz-ce"><cite class="article">Lenin and Trotsky - what they really stood for</cite> | <ref name="uy-u"><cite class="article">Russian Revolution: Triumph or Tragedy</cite> {{YouTube|1UyhO1hMhrU}}</ref> | ||
<ref name="qhz"><cite class="article">The Relevance of Marxism Today</cite> {{YouTube|qHz_PbKs6Jo}}</ref> | |||
<ref name="zz-ce"><cite class="article">Lenin and Trotsky - what they really stood for</cite> {{YouTube|Z-ZICRekmCE}}</ref> | |||
<!-- <ref name="unk">Video unknown.</ref> --> | <!-- <ref name="unk">Video unknown.</ref> --> | ||
</references> | </references> | ||
Latest revision as of 09:59, 30 January 2026
Background
Rating subject: YouTube video channel @revcomintern
- This is a Trotskyist theory channel.
- This channel's content is somewhere between popular level and academic level in difficulty.
- This channel speaks about Marxist history and world events, typically editorializing the former through Trotskyism.
- This channel holds to models of a global Marxist revolution. It does not necessarily give any clear guidance on the general structure of a world workers' state.
- This channel should be rated for accurate retellings of historical events, accurate facts about material reality and people's general experiences, and the clarity of its theories. Models which describe Trotskyist parties or interaction with workers' movements as distinguished from any conditions in the background should be evaluated for clarity and coherence, while anything that would apply outside of Trotskyism in mainstream Marxism-Leninism — including history — should be evaluated for factual accuracy. If history is a major theme of the talk but it gets history wrong, it can be marked NG.
- alias (en) [string]
- Revolutionary Communist International
- field, scope, or group [Item]
- Trotskyism
MediaWiki:Hue-ins-open-bracket/(top-level category)MediaWiki:Hue-ins-close-bracket/1-1-1 - International Marxist Tendency (proposed; IV)1
-1-1 - academic-level material
- popular-level material
- approximate number of entries
- 453
Rating sheet[edit]
Motifs[edit]
- The ruling class will not attack an idea which is dead [1] -> that seems pretty dubious if you've ever seen capitalists try to attack Black civil rights movements as literally Communism.
- Bolshevism is nonviolent until capitalists attack it [2]
- Stalin's Marxism does not create fascism [3] -> well... that's true. it does expose quite a contradiction in Trotskyism though. Trotskyism always goes around saying Stalin and all his followers were dictators. which.... you can see how that would invite accusations that Trotskyists are just as bad. stand with Stalin in your own world class war, Trotsky, and you wouldn't be in this mess.
Additional remarks[edit]
- This channel has been around a long time, in internet terms, and had at least two names.