Ontology:Q76,84

1. [M3]
   Would you kill a Russian in order to vote? 1:(-)1:(-)1

Core characteristics

item type

M3 1:(-)1:(-)1

[P] (pronounced [P]) label [string] (L)

[M3]

Would you kill a Russian in order to vote? 1:(-)1:(-)1

E:VoterCardForOneRussian

[P] (pronounced [P]) alias (en) [string]

--

QID references [Item] 1:(-)1:(-)1

--

field, scope, or group [Item]

--

case of [Item]

jamming question 1:(-)1:(-)1

sub-case of [Item]

--

super-case of [Item]

--

Appearances

appears in work [Item]

--

Wavebuilder combinations

[P] (pronounced [P]) Wavebuilder (pronounced Wavebuilder): forms result [Item]

--

along with [Item]

--

forming from [Item]

--

--

--

Wavebuilder characterizations

Wavebuilder (pronounced Wavebuilder): route [Item]

--

along with [Item]

--

forming from [Item]

--

--

--

Prototype notes

7684. Would you kill a Russian in order to vote? / Would you kill a Russian to receive your voter card? -> you live in an alternate world where every individual in the United States is entitled to a voting license the day they kill a Russian. policies are mostly the same. voting brings anti-discrimination laws, healthcare programs, whatever. but you have to kill someone in Eurasia to get to vote, or to get to tell anyone else to vote. want people to vote for gun control? every one of them has to fly over and shoot a Russian, and then you can have it. the central question of this thought experiment is this: how much is voting worth? what lengths is it worth going to just to preserve voting and the "normal" process of getting people to vote? would people chant "vote Democrat" as loudly if every one of them was required to kill a Russian? what about if voting Democrat really does take a little power away from Tories to create more structural racism and kill Black people? should everyone go kill a Russian just to save Black people from fascism? or is preserving the life of Russians more important than that aim? the only thing about this metaphor that's incoherent to me is how you prove anyone actually killed anyone. uh. maybe there are a limited number of voter licenses, and you'd just take one from Russia and hold it up. or maybe everyone has an ID card which clearly has a flag on it and you'd take that. there may or may not be a system where any country can kill people to issue voter licenses but just as in real life most countries are too afraid to attack the United States. also you equally get a point if you kill a United States Communist and it can be proven in court, even though they deliberately don't have different id card flags. in this world people go to court to prove they have done approved heinous things as well as to prove they're innocent.