Ontology:Q65,47: Difference between revisions
m page alias: The Soviet Union functioned as a political faction |
description / alias |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{ArticleTitle|[S2] Soviet Union functioned as a political faction - HAS / Q65,47|NoContents=y}} | |||
<onlyinclude><dfn class="field_exstruct manual" data-dimension="S2" data-qid="65,47" data-numbersign="404" data-series=" | <includeonly><onlyinclude><dfn class="{{{class|field_exstruct}}} manual" data-dimension="S2" data-qid="65,47" data-numbersign="404" data-series="" data-work="" data-object="" data-note="" data-lexeme="">{{IS2/HAS}}{{#if: {{{1|}}} | [[E:Q65,47|{{{1}}}]] | [[E:Q65,47|The {{TTS|tts=Soviet Union|USSR}} functioned as a political faction]] }}{{#if: {{{3|}}} | {{{3}}} }}{{#if: {{{2|}}} | <ins class="edition-sense term"> ([[E:Q65,47/{{{2}}}|{{{2}}}]]<nowiki />)</ins> }}{{WaveScore|sum=1|quilt=1|ply=1}}</dfn></onlyinclude></includeonly><!-- | ||
</ | -->{{HueNumberPreview|E=Q6547}}<!-- duplication hint: copy or update fake Item from [[Special:PermanentLink/NNNN|Q65,47]] --> | ||
== Core characteristics == | == Core characteristics == | ||
| Line 7: | Line 7: | ||
<dl class="wikitable hue"> | <dl class="wikitable hue"> | ||
{{HueClaim |P=item type| {{Template:S2}} }} | {{HueClaim |P=item type| {{Template:S2}} }} | ||
{{HueRoster|EP=PPPA/L|lang=en| {{E:Q65,47}} | | {{HueRoster|EP=PPPA/L|lang=en| {{E:Q65,47}} | {{E:Q6547|class=field_ML|The {{TTS|tts=Soviet Union|USSR}} functioned as a proletarian faction|ML}} }} | ||
{{HueClaim |EP=PPPA|lang=en| During the Cold War the Soviet Union functioned as a political faction | During the Cold War the Soviet Union served as one of the world's capable proletarian subpopulations, and thus Soviet politicians in general had a partisan alignment with the proletariat even if not every one of them was perfect }} | {{HueClaim |EP=PPPA|lang=en| [[E:The Soviet Union functioned as a political faction|The Soviet Union functioned as a political faction]] | During the Cold War the Soviet Union functioned as a political faction | During the Cold War the Soviet Union served as one of the world's capable proletarian subpopulations, and thus Soviet politicians in general had a partisan alignment with the proletariat even if not every one of them was perfect | <strong>During the Cold War the Soviet Union functioned as a socially-linked population of people aligned toward a particular model of the world and against other blocs of people clustered toward other ideologies and philosophical models, regardless of whether its ideology was good or bad</strong> (canonical) }} | ||
{{HueRoster|EP=P42| exact or approximate historical date | Cold War }} <!-- en: QID references --> | {{HueRoster|EP=P42| {{E:Q618/HAS|exact or approximate historical date}} | {{E:Q618/ES|Cold War}} }} <!-- en: QID references --> | ||
{{HueRoster|EP=P34| {{E:Q618/ES|Liberal-republican history}} | {{E:Q618/ML|mainstream Marxism-Leninism}} }} | {{HueRoster|EP=P34| {{E:Q618/ES|Liberal-republican history}} | {{E:Q618/ML|mainstream Marxism-Leninism}} }} | ||
{{HueRoster|EP=P3| -- }} <!-- en: subset of --> | {{HueRoster|EP=P3| -- }} <!-- en: subset of --> | ||
| Line 30: | Line 30: | ||
<dl class="wikitable hue data_wavebuild three"> | <dl class="wikitable hue data_wavebuild three"> | ||
{{WaveBuildNone| {{E:Q65,47}} | | {{WaveBuildNone| {{E:Q65,47}} | {{E:Q65,10}} | {{E:Q65,17}} }} <!-- en: Along With, Produces Love your neighbor, regardless of ideology God wants us to love Leninists --> | ||
</dl> | </dl> | ||
| Line 36: | Line 36: | ||
<dl class="wikitable hue data_wavebuild three"> | <dl class="wikitable hue data_wavebuild three"> | ||
{{WaveRoute| -- | -- | {{E:Q65,47}} }} <!-- en: | {{WaveRoute| -- | -- | {{E:Q65,47}} }} <!-- en: From ?? ?? --> | ||
</dl> | </dl> | ||
== Usage notes == | == Usage notes == | ||
This claim is not very controversial. It is more or less the standard view of the Cold War in North America, and likely to be stated or implied in a typical history book. | |||
=== Color swatch === | |||
This Item was assigned the <code>HAS</code> philosophy tag (blue) in reference to standard Liberal-republican history. | |||
The Marxist variant of the proposition (<code>ML</code> / crimson) is the same except that it explicitly references the Soviet Union being aligned with an ideology <em>of the proletariat</em>. The core of the proposition is still that the 14 union republics of the Soviet Union were all aligned around a particular political ideology. | |||
=== Falsification criteria === | |||
To falsify this claim, it would have to be shown that the Soviet Union primarily behaved according to a different model than the model of people joining around a political ideology of building a particular kind of republic or of people joining together around particular class features and class-structures to generate ideology incidentally, instead operating according to some comparatively non-political model such as being the Soviet Union solely on the basis of the 14 union republics being part of a greater whole <em>primarily because</em> because they feel like they are already joined by the same culture and are part of the same ethnic group. Note that statements by Communist parties that the 14 union republics "will one day become" the same continuous countable culture do not count as them already being the same culture; these statements directly imply that the merging of cultures has not yet happened. | |||
The ability to successfully show that Marxism was largely incidental to uniting the 14 union republics into a greater country or that some other ideology would have been just as effective at both liberating and uniting the 14 nationalities and defeating the Russian Empire would be a win for anarchism, related [[:Category:Existentialist-Structuralist tradition ontology|Existentialist-Structuralist]] philosophies, and postcolonial theories against Marxism, as well as opening the gates to potential arguments that the opposition of Liberal-republican countries against the Soviet Union was [[E:the spoon is solid until you know it's simulated|a social construct that can be deconstructed]]. | |||
[[Category:Pages serving as current format examples]] | |||
Latest revision as of 10:58, 2 September 2025
- pronounced [S2] The pronounced USSR functioned as a political faction 1-1-1
Core characteristics[edit]
- item type
- S2 (pronounced C) 1-1-1
- pronounced [P] label [string] (L)
- pronounced [S2] The pronounced USSR functioned as a political faction 1-1-1
- pronounced [S2] The pronounced USSR functioned as a proletarian faction (ML) 1-1-1
- pronounced [P] alias (en) [string]
- The Soviet Union functioned as a political faction
- During the Cold War the Soviet Union functioned as a political faction
- During the Cold War the Soviet Union served as one of the world's capable proletarian subpopulations, and thus Soviet politicians in general had a partisan alignment with the proletariat even if not every one of them was perfect
- During the Cold War the Soviet Union functioned as a socially-linked population of people aligned toward a particular model of the world and against other blocs of people clustered toward other ideologies and philosophical models, regardless of whether its ideology was good or bad (canonical)
- QID references [Item] 1-1-1
- field, scope, or group [Item]
- sub-case of [Item]
- --
- case of [Item]
- --
- super-case of [Item]
- --
Wavebuilder combinations[edit]
- pronounced [P] pronounced Wavebuilder: forms result [Item]
- pronounced [S2] God wants us to love Leninists 1-1-1
- along with [Item]
- pronounced [S2] The pronounced USSR functioned as a political faction 1-1-1
- forming from [Item]
- pronounced [S2] The pronounced USSR functioned as a political faction 1-1-1
- pronounced [S2] Love your neighbor, regardless of ideology 1-1-1
- pronounced [S2] God wants us to love Leninists 1-1-1
Wavebuilder characterizations[edit]
- pronounced Wavebuilder: route [Item]
- pronounced [S2] The pronounced USSR functioned as a political faction 1-1-1
- along with [Item]
- --
- forming from [Item]
- --
- --
- pronounced [S2] The pronounced USSR functioned as a political faction 1-1-1
Usage notes[edit]
This claim is not very controversial. It is more or less the standard view of the Cold War in North America, and likely to be stated or implied in a typical history book.
Color swatch[edit]
This Item was assigned the HAS philosophy tag (blue) in reference to standard Liberal-republican history.
The Marxist variant of the proposition (ML / crimson) is the same except that it explicitly references the Soviet Union being aligned with an ideology of the proletariat. The core of the proposition is still that the 14 union republics of the Soviet Union were all aligned around a particular political ideology.
Falsification criteria[edit]
To falsify this claim, it would have to be shown that the Soviet Union primarily behaved according to a different model than the model of people joining around a political ideology of building a particular kind of republic or of people joining together around particular class features and class-structures to generate ideology incidentally, instead operating according to some comparatively non-political model such as being the Soviet Union solely on the basis of the 14 union republics being part of a greater whole primarily because because they feel like they are already joined by the same culture and are part of the same ethnic group. Note that statements by Communist parties that the 14 union republics "will one day become" the same continuous countable culture do not count as them already being the same culture; these statements directly imply that the merging of cultures has not yet happened.
The ability to successfully show that Marxism was largely incidental to uniting the 14 union republics into a greater country or that some other ideology would have been just as effective at both liberating and uniting the 14 nationalities and defeating the Russian Empire would be a win for anarchism, related Existentialist-Structuralist philosophies, and postcolonial theories against Marxism, as well as opening the gates to potential arguments that the opposition of Liberal-republican countries against the Soviet Union was a social construct that can be deconstructed.