User:Reversedragon/FirstNineThousand/6000

6000 - 8000

Publishing entities, "Journey to the West" related Signifiers.

Entries for miscellaneous fictional works allowed. To be included, a work should have interesting literary motifs seen in multiple other works, include references to some kind of philosophical statement within some real-world philosophy, or include consistent fictional ontologies of imagined physics or processes. Fictional physics or processes also allowed.

6000. fictional character
6001. first-person narrator
6002. second-person narrator -> see: Homestuck, narrator Chara
6003. third-person narrator
6004. narrator
6005. point-of-view character
6006. player character
6007. non-player character (NPC)
6008. hero
6009. villain
6010. antihero
6011. antivillain
6012. Good-aligned character
6013. Neutral-aligned character
6014. Evil-aligned character
6015. Lawful-aligned character
6016. Chaotic-aligned character
6017. True-Neutral-aligned character
6018. character alignment / moral alignment
6019. I contain multitudes / I am all of me -> I suppose the closest tradition tag is Jungian psychoanalysis, given how it speaks about all the different "sides" of a single personality.
6020. alignment axis
6021. Law-Chaos axis -> in the first edition of Dungeons & Dragons alignment had nothing to do with Good and Evil and this was actually bordering on historical materialism; it was a mechanism for studying how fantasy history progresses. a Lawful/Chaotic distinction is outright originally intended to set up situations like an empire versus unruly peasants, or "built on the ashes of fae bones". a video creator tried to explain this by saying "in World War II, Britain won't ally with the Nazis", specifically meaning in this case that regardless of who is Evil particular nationalities or populations join up to defend some particular order or against a particular structure or ideology. Lawful/Chaotic is a lot like the Cold War: if capitalists are on the side of Law then unions are on the side of Chaos, although if a workers' state is created Bolshevism is the side of Law in its own region and the 1930s Trotskyite conspiracy is the side of Chaos. to be Lawful is simply to be on the side of a particular civilization or in modern terms an assembled Bauplan, while to be on the side of Chaos is to be against some highly specific order. the major "mistake" made with alignment across various fantasy media as time went on is to not realize that civilizations can be plural and to universalize Law as belonging to the whole universe rather than there being several different centers of Law such that in something like the Wings of Fire setting with different coalitions of warring dragons, you would have to be aligned to Lawful-A or Lawful-B, a single universal "Lawful" doesn't actually exist. why people make this "mistake" is complicated, but it seems connected to the choice to treat Law/Chaos as a strict cosmically-metaphysical slider where Chaos tears open all the rules of reality similar to an SCP anomaly. although fantasy can be anything, this seems like a bad choice if you want people to understand fantasy populations simply as periods of history where populations are in conflict and not as inherently Good or Evil. this mere transformation of Chaos into an alchemical quality of the universe inherently spawns implications that certain groups of people are the universe's favorites and certain groups are not, and like, trying to fix that by saying "they need to be balanced, we need both of them" is just both-sidesing medieval politics. if we literally thought that way about medieval England there would have been an ongoing controversy up to today about whether creating Liberalism and getting rid of monarchy was actually a good idea. as well, we'd be both-sidesing global empire and whether it's okay to keep people marginalized into tiny areas of l—... oh wait, we already do that every day. tabletop RPGs reveal a whole lot about Europeans, don't they?
6022. Good-Evil axis
6023. foreshadowing
6024. grayble -> a specific kind of short story which has a theme in the sense of a writing prompt but is mistaken for having symbolism or lessons when it may not really have those. graybles sound infuriating but in my mind are actually pretty respectable. you'd think, when I get mad at Existentialism so often, that I'd hate the idea. but I don't. the notion of graybles expresses itself as Adventure Time goes on through the art of making a stupid meaningless story and then explicitly being aware of that and pointing it out with unnecessarily thoughtful philosophy. and I actually like that, even as some people seem to have not understood it and hated it. it cements that the "stupid" nature of Adventure Time plots is a stylization and not something the authors do because they're bad at writing actually-good narratives, or because they're useful idiots to Liberalism/capitalism/Existentialism (although there could be a bit to unpack with that last one of the three) and make misinforming narratives because it socially supports them and pays them to.
6025. grayble foreshadowing -> when a lot of people in the audience mistake simple foreshadowing of a fictional historical event for meaningful symbolism, either unintentionally or as the author intends. I didn't really get the joke behind the graybles until seasons 8-10 when I fully identified grayble foreshadowing that was very confusable for a message about character development and was like. ah. I see it now. I think there is also a lot of grayble foreshadowing in FNaF. people genuinely take some of the clues as symbolic when they truly only refer to characters or processes or things in a superficial visual kind of way. one thing I think isn't true is that grayble foreshadowing is exactly the same as Chekov's gun, because grayble foreshadowing seems to be a statement about history in the sense of the history of fictional worlds or the history of fictional characters' lives. grayble foreshadowing is a statement that somewhat-arbitrary things drive history within fiction, but it's still history.
6026. A plan the story gives away will fail / Scooby-Doo rule -> if the story details the plan, it will fail, if it doesn't detail the plan it will probably succeed
6027. bookman's bluff / scottcon -> when a story hints something so vaguely you can't solve it and then it solves the same clues in a different way than expected later; when the story is unsolvable because it spontaneously makes up its own solutions rather than having clear processes or events-happening inside it.
6028. "Calvinball"
6029. Calvinball -> like bookman's bluff / scottcon, only it actually succeeds.
6030. All arrangements of things begin as fictions / All arrangements of people begins as ontologies (socially-constructed or imagined orders which might vaguely be possible in reality; chaos magic, Existentialist cybernetics) -> kind of. sort of. if you took this and restricted it a whole lot it would somewhat be true. like, don't connect this to Free Will, don't you dare do that, but if you managed to not go there, then yes, many things about society and even causality inside society are "put together" as a designed or undesigned construct before they are actually realized. I call them Philosophical Systems of ontologies embedded inside groups of people to produce Social-Philosophical Systems. but I am reasonably sure they're real. this + (something bad which is charcoal?) = Culture is just the series of signs people make up
6031. Kirby Does His Taxes / Mario Stands Still -> I forgot about this until somebody brought up "Mario Stands Still" to explain Deltarune. Kirby Does His Taxes will always be the better form though
6032. Science fiction is just nonsensical physics -> not very controversial. science fiction begins with physics discoveries, hypotheses in various fields of science, and the application of physics or general mathematics to create hypothetical technologies or worlds. warp drives. four-dimensional worlds. it's kind of all just applying advanced mathematics to storytelling.
6033. Fantasy is the best history test / Fantasy is just nonsensical history -> the more fantasy books I read the more I see this particular hypothesis building up that the impulse behind writing fantasy is to play with the causal mechanisms of history and try to slowly figure out what they are. science fiction can sidestep the actual way anyone gets to the future to focus on hypothetical technologies or forms of physics, but in a weird way, fantasy is almost inherently more progressive than sci-fi if you aren't too stupid to see it. although science fiction often does focus on analyzing civilizations in series such as Star Trek, fantasy is inherently more barebones in its palette of concepts in a way that often immediately forces it to reckon with the workings of societies. fantasy grounds itself in things like social structures, wars, nationalities and identities, whether particular civilizations are good or bad, who should be in power, and how imagined historical periods give way to other periods containing different civilizations. sometimes it seems like there is no difference between the categories of fantasy and politics, because a great heap of the things that happen in fantasy books are just medieval politics, and existing notions like Law/Chaos axes naturally lend themselves to fantasy stories about such things as characters slipping out of existing structures or patterns to discover LGBT identities. fantasy stories have all the puzzle pieces to turn into a believable imagined account of history where the material processes inside particular kingdoms, populations, or worlds actually unfold in understandable ways into new historical periods for centuries and centuries and you can actually trace through a fictional world's past and possible future(s) without any of it being arbitrary. if you actually understand history, fantasy is wired. I'm convinced that fantasy stories could teach the crustiest White people to actually understand historical materialism, maybe even more effectively than actual history could. in real-life history if somebody asks you to guess what happens next you always have "the answers at the back of the book", while fantasy is genuinely a blank history test you have to fill in. the act of creating fantasy is an act of showing that there really is such a thing as historical materialism and "history in general" without the content of a specific country. if that's not the case, how do people evaluate whether a fantastical history is convincing? why would there be a discussion about that where people have different opinions? I believe it all traces back to fantasy largely being simple representational art with regard to the processes that create real-world history. when people call for Media Representation in fantasy what they mean to say is that, because reality is stranger than fiction, in their attempt to represent the general concept of history current fantasy stories are overlooking a whole bunch of real-world historical events. it's one thing to say a story is technically unrealistic, and another to say it's literally missing information about reality that's making the representational art worse, which in this case is the complaint.
6034. text claims to be bunch of senseless events, becomes discussion on history / work claims to be a bunch of senseless events, ends up a discussion on history -> happened in both Adventure Time and Dragon Ball. it's funny how works that intend to show that history is senseless actually just end up discussing the proposition it can be understood. no matter how much they try to turn around and say the characters' efforts to understand it are in vain. the point of the work is still to say that not being able to understand and steer history is a problem.
6035. [S2] Unless society is magic, there will be Communism / If society does not run on magic, Marxism-Leninism is not ruled out -> follows from: The heart of Marxism is historical materialism / Proposition zero of Marxism is historical materialism
6036. ??
6037. Materialist analyses cannot truly be owned / Materialist analyses of fiction are the only ones which cannot be attacked by capitalists -> a little subjective, but a very interesting argument to step through. information which is empirically observable can never be copyrighted, no matter how bad copyright policies get. you can never truly copyright an observation such as that hydrogen and hydroxide make water, or the earth is round, or religion exists, or countries exist, or science fiction books in general exist. but how far does this go? given a complete enough ontology of every generic thing that exists, could you build a literary analysis of a work of fiction which is totally uncopyrightable to the point it can never be taken down by a copyright claim, as long as it is very clearly an analysis and not a copy of the work? I think there's reason to believe the answer is "yes". and if that's the case. every analysis of art which is based on somebody's academic theory of social construction and utopianism and ideals is vulnerable to being taken away from people when a group of bourgeoisie bands together and decides to make life difficult for people, but comparatively, Materialist analyses are impervious to this. a Third World country or cluster of workers can have all the Materialist analyses it wants to and they can never be taken away. it can build them all from the ground up at any time without needing to access anything or anyone in particular. Materialist analyses are the only thing that perfectly suits this disgusting world of copyright and spatial slot hierarchies and defining people as isolated pockets of wealth with legs and trying to divide concepts up into people and make them totally synonymous with toxic gatekeepers and claiming that China building civilization again in parallel to the United States is "stealing" the inherent containment of concepts and culture-simply-existing into toxic individuals; if that's going to continue this is the one thing that can exist alongside all that and survive all that. Materialist analyses are even resilient to Marxisms fracturing into different blocs and denying things from each other. basically, if you want knowledge and palettes of artistic concepts to survive nearly anything, create a Materialist analysis and stay far, far away from artisanal conceptions of anything which even open the door for it to have an official shop or an official inventor. no library of Alexandria can be burned which was never inherently Greek.
6038. Fiction doesn't teach us anything -> Aron Ra's proposition. I don't think it's true, on a subtle level of failing the question-begging test. it's technically accurate to say fiction doesn't contain any educational information. but that's not what people usually mean by the statement "fiction teaches us". they are referring to a more abstract notion of learning by picking up general patterns and comparing analogies to the real world — a process of building ontological models through true or untrue scenarios using every scenario as a thought experiment. if you do that systematically enough it's essentially similar to applying a scientific method in different environments, although it entails you'll probably stop believing in Christianity after reading a few secular books and the bible and trying to compare all of them to each other and real life.
6039. Fiction is educational -> for a very long time I had a hard time believing this, although I never would have said that fiction doesn't teach people about creating art or about using language — only that there is an open question on whether it teaches people about ""life"". typically when people say this they mean that it teaches about "experiences", and gives people a model of a demographic of people without exclusively boxing them into a stereotype.
6040. Narratives exist to portray possible societies or situations -> this answer is fully compatible with historical materialism, or at least existential materialism. it allows weaving ties between the individual and historical period.
6041. Narratives exist to depict each possible kind of individual / Narratives exist to tell us about individuals -> this is the answer I do not like. it's drenched in intentional or unintentional psychoanalysis. and I'd argue it ultimately encourages racism, simply because it encourages treating past hardships as irrelevant to current individual lives while treating the successes of current individuals as un-repeatable flukes. without a causal analysis of history and historical patterns you lose the ability to argue for consistent and cumulative social progress really quickly.
6042. Why do narratives exist?
6043. Non-fiction doesn't teach us anything -> counter to Aron Ra's proposition. if you actually understand the way people learn, though ontological models and metaphors, it's easy to see how a factual book could fail to teach people anything because they can't understand it through their current models and fail to believe that it looks plausible. in some cases people don't learn well through facts and learn better through questions. but I think the "street epistemology" concept is shortsighted too, because you have to ask what it is about questions that actually makes them work.
6044. fake historical period / fake, bad history -> the motif of bad events in history being treated as a detour from "real" history. this motif is orange because, quite honestly, this is exactly what the Trotskyite conspiracy was alleging against Stalin's government, whether you commandeer Zinovievism as supposedly being Liberalism or whether you interpret it as saying Trotskyism is the real history. (my response, always: then why hasn't it happened yet??) famously this motif also comes up in the Christian bible, with the hypothetical reign of the antichrist being a kind of fake historical period, or the reign of the Roman emperors being suggested as one.
6045. The only explanation of history is the defiance of history / The only explanation of historical patterns is the defiance of historical patterns -> this claim is inherently contradictory because it proposes an explanation of history, which is forbidden by the claim; the claim forbids itself. there is one way to fix it: cross out the word "defiance" and propose that Free Will and The Subject are material phenomena which can themselves be studied by historical materialism and reduced down to a number of partly-predictable patterns. this produces existential materialism.
6046. The only explanation of defying history is history / The only explanation of the defiance of historical patterns is historical patterns -> fixed it. funny how if you say almost the exact opposite of what Existentialists say it actually begins to make sense again.
6047. History is the progression of family units / History is the progression of lines of Lived Experiences -> psychohistory proposition, often casually put forward by many people who have no idea what Lacanianism or psychohistory is, simply because Existentialism Is The Simplest Philosophy Which Everybody Already Believes. recently tossed out as an explanation for how war veterans coming back causes damage to family unit psychology, and presumably to national culture. [1] something is wrong with this logic: okay, but what causes countries to go to war and rack up trauma in the first place?
      tangent: this came up in My Pride, the questionably-written show about the lions. and it caught me off guard because I immediately noticed that choosing to interpret tribal culture as a progression of family units instead of as history is an active choice you make that can editorialize and ideologically frame the events of the story if you're not careful.
6048. History is the progression of groups operating -> this claim entails that even if the study of historical materialism up to now is wrong or lacking, Bolshevism could still be correct for reasons other than the reasons it believed to be its explanation. namely, Bolshevism could be correct because it is a sensible method of ordering people into a nation-state and functional nation-states are nearly fundamental.
6049. History is the progression of class struggles / All history ... is the history of class struggles -> have to get the classic one in there. not really exclusive with "history is the progression of groups operating", as these two things simply happen on different scales. group operating (countable area of capitalism), class struggle, rupture, group operating (named Marxism). the only serious difference is that "groups operating" allows modeling Trotskyism as its own phenomenon in parallel to mainstream Marxism-Leninism, or different anarchisms, an instance of Deng Xiaoping Thought, etc.
6050. Biographies only have one ending -> this is one of the falsest things I have ever heard that people still keep saying. literally using biographies as the example the whole point of reading them is that different things happen in them, meaning they have different endings. this is a very important distinction because this difference in "endings" provides a material difference which can become a pattern that can be studied and in some cases broadly repeated.
6051. Because all biographies have one ending, we can only reinterpret them -> no. is that how people created the underground railroad and slipped out of slavery? reinterpreting how bad they think their situation is and how bad it is or isn't to inevitably die? this is one of the only things worse than saying Free Will explains all history.
6052. Biographies have many different endings -> I don't have an example text right now but I swear the Bolshevik party knew this. look at what happened afterward. before 1900 people in Russia and China had one kind of ending. after 1930 their stories had new kinds of endings. this is almost the definition of what history is. if people didn't have different endings, we'd all live in an episodic sitcom and nothing would build on anything else.
6053. The life of a bisexual has at least two endings / The biography of a bisexual has at least two possible endings -> this seems pretty self-evident, yet somehow nobody thinks of it. bisexuals break psychoanalysis. and they break Existentialism because there isn't necessarily an inherently better individual choice, but there are still multiple outcomes.
6054. Boring relationships in Warriors happen due to psychohistorical biases -> if you think the story of an individual life has only one ending, it's awfully tempting to slot every single individual into the same trite, boring heterosexual romance. diversity of gender and sexuality alone leads to multiple endings.
6055. ??
6060. ??
6065. ??
6066. ??
6067. Some of Western Marxism isn't Marxism / Most of Western Marxism isn't Marxism -> the claim that adding early-existentialism to Marxism may turn it into not being Marxism because it encourages replacing historical materialism with historical existentialism. or similar rather-specific claims involving particular parts of Western "Marxism".
6068. Lacanianism aims to replace historical materialism with psychohistory / Freudians are trying to create a non-Marxist replacement for historical materialism, and that alternative is psychohistory -> I could really tell something was up with Lacanianism shortly after I heard of it but had so much trouble fully explaining exactly what they were trying to replace Marxism with. I'm more confident now that I found the actual name of the thing. Rothenberg and Žižek's whole weird bridge about Heidegger is this: Marx bad because the development of populations is the physical and intellectual development of a cloud of brains. what they don't realize is that this is equating history with culture. practically speaking, the total or average behavior of a cloud of individuals is that group's culture. so if you think history is most explainable through psychology, you're pretty much necessarily asking how the culture of a group of people develops and why people are Spanish or German — as well as how they could stop being Spanish when they happen to have a definition of what their country means to them which is bad. this is so much more offensive than Marxism, because if Marxism says bad things about "the bourgeoisie" or what should happen to them, it also makes no serious effort to mess with what anybody believes to be Chinese or North Korean, and limits itself to the practical study of how an existing group of people can build a republic, industrial structures, and various possible stages of development. the premise of psychohistory implies there are superior and inferior Cultures and societal transition means transitioning Cultures into a different Culture. the implication of Deleuze & Guattari's concept of "plateaus" next to psychohistory existing unchallenged (though that relationship is only "as far as I can tell") is that separating Germany off into East Germany and West Germany is bad but staying "in-between" by making people not be Germans and making them all be Better Germans is okay. what makes people go for this? what makes us think this kind of framework is acceptable?
6069. Deltarune is an example of historical existentialism [2] -> the claim that Deltarune broadly (not necessarily super literally) embodies the concept of treating history as something that can always be defied; this claim is blue because an Existentialist also could and would make this claim. to be precise, Deltarune only talks about prophecies and narratives, but whether in reality or fiction history is a narrative, so the claim would be that Deltarune throwing around tropes about prophecies and narratives is significant because these tropes resonate with the way players intuitively want to understand history. you can see a similar thing going on in Wings of Fire: wars in a Europe-like "fantasy World War I" setting should be a matter of history, but again history is being spun solely as a matter of Free Will, especially in the Pantala arc which is literally covering the history of where the earliest wars came from. back to Deltarune: there is a really really common motif people have when talking about it: the only kind of story there can ever possibly be is the story of an individual life, therefore, all discussions about prophecy tropes are appropriate to relate back to a single human life cycle and the fact they all end in death, the "one ending" to life. only.... that is not true. that is not even true. you'd know this if you live in the United States, where some people died slaves and some people died free. that's not the same ending! people genuinely have different endings to their lives because of the fact history exists. it's flat out beneficial to racists to pretend that everyone has the same life cycle and the same ending, because if everybody's life begins and ends the same way they can then act like the era of slavery is totally irrelevant and can be left out of history books just because it's not happening any more. the really sad thing is that progressive Existentialism will put this lesson into the meat grinder too, by claiming that slavery is a deviation from history rather than being part of history, because the only real history is the history created by Free Will, and everything else is fake history, essentially. fake history that bad people concocted the contents of and then enacted but which overall taught people nothing and got in the way of real correct history unfolding that would actually teach people something. but, again, if bad history isn't real history there's a terrifyingly good argument to leave it out of textbooks, because if only Free Will matters in writing the future, wouldn't it be better to leave out everything White supremacists ever did and fill textbooks only with progressive incidents that taught people how to build the future? I hate that idea but I'm just a dumb Communist, I'm not an expert, intelligent postcolonial anarchist Lacanian. so you know, I've gotta stop being such a freedom-hating dictator for just a moment and give the actual "good" ideas a try.
6070. player as relative to game
6080. anachronistic technology / technological anachronism
6081. Technology shows what year a story takes place in / Technology can be used to tell what historical period of the world a story takes place in -> that would be true if you knew exactly what country was the most accurate to compare it to and mapped out all the historical periods of that country.
      as for the whole world... wouldn't you have to factor in global empire, and separate the local creation (enforcement) of colonial periods from before that? technology doesn't seem like as big a change as a whole colonial period falling down on India or Africa. is this why people are so obsessed with the word "colonialism"? because they can't conceptualize history as not being the history of the whole world and are trying to map out the whole world's colonial period? the problem is that's still stupid. Spain can't stop France's colonial period if it wanted to; they're going to be separate colonial periods. there's not really any such thing as a single world colonial period as far as the question of preventing it.
6082. ??
6083. 80 years before 2003, there were fast cars / 80 years before 2003, there were 60-mile-per-hour cars (96 kilometers per hour; anachronistic device) / 80 years before 2003, there were wrecking balls [3] -> a funny little reasoning error that can be found in books taking place in a particular time period which aren't primarily meant as historical fiction but end up reaching decades into the past. pointed out by many people analyzing Warriors.
6084. ??
6085. ??
6086. ??
6087. ??
6088. The history of slavery doesn't belong in textbooks -> no need to spend much time on the actual reactionary arguments, none of which are worth anything. I'm much more interested in the potential arguments that teaching about the history of racism is theoretically unnecessary for anti-racists just because most of them reject historical materialism, and if historical materialism is truly unnecessary and you really can fix everything with Free Will and protests and inclusion and Community, the hardships of the past should in theory be less relevant than the study of actively constructing the future. I feel like what I've really uncovered is the potential racism of anarchism, how utopian thinking could potentially crush people of various demographics under the material hardships they currently face which stand in the way of simply moving on.
6089. An ending amid slavery is a different outcome / An ending amid slavery is different from an ending amid none / A book that ends within a time of slavery is a different ending than a book which ends in a time of no slavery -> apparently ordinary people are too stupid for this proposition to be blue, and that's a shame.
6090. An ending amid monarchy is a different outcome -> the charcoal swatch manages this one because Wings of Fire was able to figure out this much, although the ultimate implications of the books are... odd. it's left, like Warriors, implying that monarchy is bad but endless brutality and death between nationalities is almost better and needs no real apologies.
6098. speedrun
6099. challenge run
6100. seemingly-impossible challenge run
6101. but first we need to talk about parallel universes
6105. ??
6109. ??
6110. An RPG world is a cultural fabrication / An RPG world is a social construct or magic circle, or "game" in the Idealist linguistics sense / Given a particular console RPG world such as Moon or Undertale, an RPG world is a cultural fabrication (idea-based fabrication; Idealism) / An RPG world is a magic circle, and this means all of it is at least somewhat arbitrary
6111. fantasy war as cultural fabrication / fantasy war as social construct (idea-based fabrication; Idealism) -> this is Q61,10 in reference to books, or anything.
6112. RPG war as cultural fabrication / RPG war as social construct (idea-based fabrication; Idealism) -> this is Q61,10 in reference to tabletop or video games but not books.
6113. RPG world as cultural fabrication / RPG universe or cosmos as cultural fabrication -> Q61,10 as a basic assumption of a work.
6114. shutting down story as horror / shutting down fictional narrative as destroying story characters -> although it's difficult to fully guess where Deltarune is going, this seems to be the major twist versus Undertale, which Ralsei unsubtly hints toward in Chapters 3-4. Undertale presents you with the thesis that the monsters can be freed if you just choose to; Deltarune poses a more difficult question of whether you can ever free the characters the way it appears they are in Undertale if they stop existing when the game shuts off.
6115. ??
6116. RPG progression as horror / game progression as horror -> Undertale; Deltarune chapter 3; FNaF Security Breach & Gregory destroying not-so-scary artificial beings.
6117. Game worlds are not cultural fabrications -> a little controversial. this claim is not an absolute one about all situations, and it rests on the concept that recognizing game or book worlds as imagined material systems of parts is actually one of the major things that helps connect them to history and become aware of how they have been influenced by empire, country-internal racism, and populational prejudices that have followed historical events. said another way: coding is to individuals as fictional material-history is to real history. some people still won't like this claim. and to them what I will say is: if Idealism fully explains fiction, then Stalin's government commissioning books full of proletarian values can convince everyone to abandon capitalism. do you think such an initiative would work on you? if not, reconsider Idealism.
6118. Novels about Communism can change everyone's minds / If fictional narratives are truly social constructs, and writing a book that rewrites all the social constructs can truly change people's way of thinking about how to regenerate society when it comes to things like empire or prejudices or the environment, then handing everyone a book that accurately represents Bolshevism will make everyone stop regenerating Liberalism and turn people into Communists -> I really don't believe this is true by itself but it's definitely funny.
6119. ??
6120. ??
6130. ??
6135. ??
6140. ??
6144. Trotsky's writings describe a parallel universe / Trotsky's writings describe a parallel reality where different things happened (counterfactual statement or thought experiment) -> this was the concept of an SCP article I was trying to write semi-recently. I don't know if I'll finish it. either way, the basic idea is now here in case it proves useful for illustrating something else.
6145. ??
6149. ??
6150. ??
6160. ??
6173. SCP Foundation Wikis
6174. SCP foundation database -> runs narratively parallel to: Pokédex. it killed me when a commenter on an audiobook said "the SCP Foundation is just playing Pokémon on impossible difficulty". yeah, sure, I mean, they both have a serialized index of things
6180. elemental card color (Arcmage)
6181. ??
6182. ??
6183. Gaian card / earth color card (darkmage)
6184. Red Banner card / sun color card (darkmage)
6185. ??
6186. House of Nobles card / sea color card (darkmage)
6187. Empire card / steel color card (darkmage)
6188. Shadow Legion card / death color card (darkmage) -> I arranged these in rough order of good to evil because I wasn't sure there was a particular established faction ring for this game. this is/was the order used by darkmage prototypes. but you've gotta put Red Banner at 84, come on.
6189. ??
6190. elemental card color (Magic)
6191. Pokémon Go teams are evil organizations / Pokémon Go teams represent evil organizations -> the devs kind of invited this theory by improperly using the word "Team" when it already had a use in Pokémon referring to fantasy mafias. never a substantial theory but definitely a funny writers' error to point out.
6192. Pokémon Go teams represent sectarian Marxisms -> cracktheory / joke interpretation. it's very funny to imagine a world where that was actually the case though. imagine three legendary Pokémon but one is Trotskyism (valor), one is Gramscianism (instinct), and one is... uh. um. MDem? it's purple. it's purple and it's sharp and cutting. I hate that but I almost like that.
6193. Pokémon Go teams resemble world wars / Pokémon Go teams represent warring kingdoms -> this is what I've thought there's always been an argument for. graph struggle itself makes its way into games accidentally when they copy earlier games more closely based on history. earlier games are war games with world maps or board game battles; fantasy games mindlessly copy patterns of empire. with Pokémon Go... let's think about it. we begin with Ingress. Ingress is kind of an alien invasion plot. but practically it's a war game, it has a world war structure. so yeah. Pokémon Go copied world wars but with three factions when for various reasons there's usually two.
6194. white card (Magic)
6195. blue card (Magic)
6196. black card (Magic)
6197. red card (Magic)
6198. green card (Magic) -> WUBRG; W(bU)(Bl)RG
6199. ??
6200. Magic: the Gathering (1993 - present)
6300. (62-6300: Magic: the Gathering sets, not totally exhaustive. list of sets being compiled here)
6312. Twelve things form a Chinese zodiac / Twelve things means Chinese astrology
6313. ??
6314. ??
6315. Dark Fountain
6316. Yume Nikki
6317. ??
6318. Super Sentai (metaseries) / Super Squad (unofficial name)
6319. Uchū Sentai Kyuranger [vol. 41] / Space Squad Kyuranger
6320. Power Rangers (abridged-series)
6321. Himitsu Sentai Gorenger [vol. 1] (1975) / Secret Squad Gorenger
6322. J.A.K.Q. Dengekitai [vol. 2] (1977) / JAKQ Blitz Squad
6323. Battle Fever J [vol. 3] (1979)
6324. Denshi Sentai Denziman [vol. 4] (1980) / Electric Squad Denziman / Electronic Squad Denziman
6325. Taiyo Sentai Sun Vulcan [vol. 5] (1981) / Solar Squad Sun Vulcan
6326. Dai Sentai Goggle-V [vol. 6] (1982)
6327. Kagaku Sentai Dynaman [vol. 7] (1983) / Science Squad Dynaman
6328. Chodenshi Bioman [vol. 8] (1984) / Super Electronic Squad Bioman
6329. Dengeki Sentai Changeman [vol. 9] (1985) / Blitz Squad Changeman
6330. Choshinsei Flashman [vol. 10] (1986)
6331. Hikari Sentai Maskman [vol. 11] (1987)
6332. Choju Sentai Liveman [vol. 12] (1988) / Super Beast Squad Liveman
6333. Kousoku Sentai Turboranger [vol. 13] (1989) / Lightspeed Squad Turboranger
6334. Chikyu Sentai Fiveman [vol. 14] (1990)
6335. Chojin Sentai Jetman [vol. 15] (1991) / Aviator Squad Jetman
6336. Kyoryu Sentai Zyuranger [vol. 16] (1992) / Dino Squad Zyuranger
6337. Gosei Sentai Dairanger [vol. 17] (1993)
6338. Ninja Sentai Kakuranger [vol. 18] (1994)
6339. Choriki Sentai Ohranger [vol. 19] (1995)
6330. ??
6340. ??
6350. ??
6360. ??
6370. ??
6380. ??
6390. ??
6400. ??
6410. twelve or more -> precise order of magnitude
6411. exactly twelve -> precise order of magnitude
6412. Twelve things form a European zodiac / Twelve things means European astrology
6413. Homestuck - included almost just as a joke, but the number is nice
6420. ??
6433. beam balance of justice
6440. ??
6450. ??
6460. ??
6469. "cancer" refers to crabs
6484. end-of-the-world scenario -> referencing SCP-ES-084, one of them where people think the world is going to end. but highly appropriate to put next to Homestuck, I mean that's exactly how it begins
6500. ??
6505. ??
6510. God wants us to love our neighbor regardless of ideology / God wants us to love our neighbor regardless of nationality, political party, or other distinction -> now that is a whopper if I ever saw one. you put together "nationality, political party, or other distinction" and the first thing I think of is a fucking (pronounced fucking) Trotskyist party. I think there is a really good case to be made that when you've said those three categories it totally counts. but I am pretty sure that most people wouldn't turn around and say "oh, if the United States is slated to be taken over by some kind of Leninist movement they're my neighbors so all of that is totally okay". nobody turns around and says "hey, wait, I don't think the Cold War is very Christian, I think we have to stop it".
6511. God wants us to love social-democrats / God wants us to love Mensheviks
6512. God wants us to love anarchists
6513. God wants us to welcome gay people / God wants us to welcome gay men / God wants us to welcome lesbians
6514. God wants us to welcome trans people / God wants us to welcome gender identity
6515. God wants us to welcome Black people even if they are poor
6516. God wants us to love Trotskyists
6517. God wants us to love Leninists / God wants us to love Marxists / God wants us to love Stalin-followers
6518. ??
6519. ??
6520. If all countries will be one in the end times, the world is our neighbor / If everyone will be one population in the end times, other countries are our neighbor / If everyone will be one population of Christians in the end times, but people everywhere are divided into many levels of plural populations now, then the Soviet Union was our neighbor, and we did not love our neighbor / Vietnam is our neighbor / China is our neighbor
6521. ??
6522. ??
6523. ??
6524. ??
6525. The wolf shall dwell with the lamb / The wolf and the lamb shall graze together / lion laying down with the lamb -> seen in many different bible verses, several in the book of Isaiah. perhaps one of the single most interesting things said in the Christian bible because A) it creates logically coherent narratives, even if ecologically inaccurate in the real world and B) it acts as one of the central themes driving many of the books. Q3009 "lion of kindness" should be considered a component of this proposition
6545. ??
6546. ??
6547. The Soviet Union functioned as a political faction / During the Cold War the Soviet Union functioned as a political faction / During the Cold War the Soviet Union served as one of the world's capable proletarian subpopulations, and thus Soviet politicians in general had a partisan alignment with the proletariat even if not every one of them was perfect
6550. ??
6555. The best ending is between the normal and weird routes (Deltarune)
6559. ??
6569. Progressive theorists are practically aliens / Social justice theorists speak another language -> Kankri Vantas
6600. ??
6650. ??
6600. alternate world / isekai -> super-case of: superstructural fantasy world.
6601. ??
6612. Homestuck act 5 / Hivebent
6613. The Underground
6614. Light World
6615. Dark World
6616. The Core
6617. W.D. Gaster
6618. Man behind the tree (Deltarune) / egg man (Deltarune)
6619. eggs of unclear importance
6620. The Angel (Deltarune)
6621. Kris
6622. Susie
6623. Noelle
6624. Ralsei
6625. Shadow Crystals
6626. Seam
6627. Jevil
6628. Spamton
6629. Berdly
6630. Kris was The Knight in Chapter 2 / Kris is The Knight
6631. Multiple characters are The Knight
6632. The player plays as The Angel -> what I thought to be true
6633. Noelle is The Angel -> I think this is only true in the sense of her being the "other" Angel, but might as well record it
6634. December Holiday is The Knight -> one line of reasoning is Mother 3 [4]
6635. The Knight is a knife which became a Darkner -> supposedly, knives have a "long hand"
6636. Kris gained the Red Soul after dying / Kris is dead / Kris drowned in a lake (generic)
6637. Kris fails to play the piano because they're too nervous -> the theory that the player would be able to prompt Kris to play the piano but Kris simply doesn't want to because they can't get into the right mood. [5] very good explanation in my opinion given that Kris always does the things the player selects in some particular way, like a particular tone, not provided by the player. Kris can take out the soul and pick up their knife as a passive-aggressive gesture at The Player. do you think they couldn't play a piano?
6638. ??
6639. ??
6640. ??
6641. Deltarune is a horror scenario about a world without creativity [6] / Deltarune is a horror story about networkism -> the claim is that Darkners not being able to create fiction is a relatable narrative for art creators. interesting theory, even if I don't see much evidence right now
6642. magic as bending the world to one's individual will / magic as the ability to inflict one's Free Will on the world regardless of the consequences -> Wings of Fire series, Darkstalker, Deltarune chapter 2 weird route. note very closely that Noelle is called a spellcaster, and her attacks to turn Darkners back into unmoving objects (!) are referred to as magic.
6643. Dark Fountains are created when a Lightner opens a wound in the earth
6644. Dark Fountains are created when a Lightner cracks open the limited box of reality -> combines claims: blank void outside of reality is fountain of imagination
6645. ??
6646. ??
6647. ??
6648. ??
6649. ??
6650. Ralsei's chapter 3 speech
6651. "it might be your imagination" -> several lines implying that Berdly has passed from "reality" into imagination, or rather, from the world into Kris' mind.
6659. living block tree / Darkerner puzzle [7] -> found in Chapter 1
6660. gray characters / Goners
6661. "Goners" have been deleted from Undertale's world / Goners are something more than dead
6664. The next level below Dark Worlds is the game code -> this doesn't make any sense to me because it breaks the basic/superstructural pattern, especially when Darker-ners have been found
6665. The level below Dark Worlds is the inanimate objects inside Dark Worlds coming to life -> evidence: tree object coming to life
6666. Image_Friend is the darkness outside the game universe come to life -> haven't heard this from anybody but me but it seems quite possible visually. sure looks like nothingness with a face
6670. The level above the Light World is earth / The level above the Light World is Toby Fox's world / The level above the Light World is the real world
6671. The level above the Light World is The Angel's Heaven / The level above the Light World is technically fictional -> narratively parallel to: when you open up a Digimon show or game, the Real World and the Digital World are both technically fictional but the Real World is material and the Digital World is intangible relative to it
6680. ??
6681. ??
6682. SCP-682 "Hard-to-destroy reptile"
6683. The final tragedy is something that would prompt Ralsei to be kind to someone in order to prevent it
6684. the final tragedy / last prophecy panel
6685. ??
6686. ??
6687. Dark Shard -> an item dropped by the Roaring Knight that exists in the Dark World and is not the same entity as the Shadow Crystal, at least at the level of the TV and Tenna not being the same entity.
6688. Black Knife / Black Blade
6689. Shadow Mantle
6690. The Roaring Knight / The Knight (Deltarune)
6691. Roaring Knight sphere -> The Knight reverts into a little rotating sphere when defeated. is that just a cool move, or is that actually the thing that created it in some sense, like the Pippins showing up as dice in the monochrome pictures?
6692. TV screen glitches (Chapter 3)
6693. say it didn't snow -> appears to be tying snow to the notion of the barrier between mind and reality breaking? shows up in room of TVs in Chapter 3, Noelle says the words in weird route.
6694. "your heartbeat becomes twisted" -> quote that appears in Roaring Knight battle.
6695. guitar phone call -> seems to literally tell us what is happening and what will happen, only very cryptically.
6696. ??
6697. getting instructions from a phone / "Mike!" (implied to be but not proved to be connected to phone)
6698. The Roaring Knight is Kris' repressed memory come to life -> Deltarune chapter 3. we've gotten occasional hints there is psychoanalysis in Deltarune. A) Deltarune has several surface similarities to OMORI, which was about repressed memories; toby even acknowledged this. B) Tenna's Dark World was full of memories. C) the code 1225 is included in the Dark World presumably as a memory. D) Kris opened the fountain, but the Roaring Knight was inside the fountain as what would appear to be a Darkner, and Tenna thinks "she" opened the fountain. E) Darkners are described as a very serious absence of real-world data, like a hallucination. if this is true, you'd expect that painful thoughts that torment you when you're up at night could bleed into the Dark World or even become entire Darkners.
6699. Red Soul (Deltarune)
6700. Dragon Ball pre-reboot era
6701. Dragon Ball Kai episode 1
6867. (... Dragon Ball Kai)
6868. Madotsuki's shirt symbol shows she is empty -> pattern said to be PNG transparency or censored out shape from Madotsuki's appearance, like a missing piece; evidence through same "missing piece" showing up in Poniko's room
6869. Dragon Blazers -> note the dimension. fictional works of fiction may be marked S, though real works of fiction are marked Z.
6870. ??
6880. ??
6890. Trying hard enough enough times always makes money / Individuals having skills or good ideas always leads to making money with enough time and attempts / Wackytown fallacy -> the more people are born and compete for jobs as more unique products exist the less true this gets. MDem entry 4.4/2050 baxter
6891. Diversity should be accepted because it's useful / Being different is okay only when you're useful / Red (Angry Birds) is useful to society because he's different in the perfect way -> the proposition people pick out and regard with much confusion when they're actually looking at the Wackytown fallacy. this is more a subjective thing than an error because you probably find this proposition some places too.
6892. Rudolph was useful -> plot motif in Christmas movies or similar fictional works when a character supposedly finds acceptance for being different but it falls flat. "Rudolph was useful" is a local joke in the United States about misunderstandings that happened somewhere between Japanese speakers attempting to translate the Rudolph song and Japanese students trying to make sense of the translation. we think the bigger part of the misunderstanding occurred the second time around, as "役に立つ" can be a perfectly positive and complimentary thing to say in the moment, similar to "a towel comes in handy wherever you go", and not very similar to the flat and uncaring connotation of "was useful".
6900. ??
6910. ??
6911. ??
6912. December Holiday / Dess Holiday
6913. ??
6914. SCP-914
6920. ??
6930. ??
6940. ??
6950. ??
6960. ??
6969. unsuitable Item label -> an Item for softly enforcing the policy that there are certain things that cannot be in outward-facing Item labels. whenever somebody might make a badly-worded Item label like "Lynching is a form of direct action", you redirect it to this so it can't practically be used to share or link Items.
6970. Garfield
6971. John Arbuckle (character)
6972. Garfield (character)
6973. Garfield minus Garfield -> Garfield + absence.
6974. ??
6975. The Secret of Platform 13 (Ibbotson 1994) -> somebody pointed out that this one came before Harry Potter and I laughed. good catch.
6976. ??
6977. ??
6978. ??
6979. Flip-flopped (Shorty McShort Shorts) -> the precursor to Growing Around. not a lot of thought was put into it, it was primarily a visual gag. really, MrEnter did a decent job taking this short specifically and making there actually be a qualitative differerence between children in charge and adults in charge. whether the difference he chose to portray actually makes any sense or not is another question.
6980. Growing Around (unreleased series with ~1 published book)
6981. Growing Around: Party Panic
6982. Growing Around: The Official Comic [8] -> team member accuses Tory boss obsessed with 9/11 of catering to "audience of progressives"? what. remove this entry if the comic isn't finished on par with the book. can't check right now
6983. In Soviet Russia, adults rule you (Growing Around) -> the claim that in the Growing Around universe, adults invented Communism and had to be defeated specifically on the logic that kids being in charge is Freedom. kids assert that them being in charge of the world is just the "tent of freedom poles" principle and adults wanting to take down their system of creativity and ideals are just tyrannical dictators. adults believe in Materialism, kids believe in Idealism, kids somehow suppress the adults with the power they mysteriously had from the beginning and gloat about how only when people believe in everyone having freedom and having freedom separately in parallel all as individuals can the world function properly, complete with a bunch of dubious or made-up information about their version of the French Revolution. it sounds like one of those very simple nonfiction picture books you find at a library, but maybe phrased a little sillier.
6984. Growing Around is a dystopia
6985. Growing Around will end with a defector / Growing Around will end with a single pair of adults running away and raising a kid normally -> the one really really good thing about Growing Around is that it comes across as so horrifying to adults that it prompts reviewers to imagine societal transitions. I love that. the theories of transition usually aren't high quality, but you know, in a time where Marxism has still never successfully become un-forbidden and nobody ever thinks about transitions in real-world society it still is actually making people think.
      thought 2: this theory sounds almost identical to the ending of The Giver. I suppose I will label this anarchism because of that association.
6986. ??
6987. ??
6988. ??
6989. ??
6990. ??
7000. ??
7001. ??
7002. ??
7003. ??
7004. ??
7005. ??
7006. ??
7007. ??
7008. ??
7009. ??
7010. ??
7011. ??
7012. ??
7013. ??
7014. ??
7015. ??
7016. Marxists Internet Archive
7017. Moscow: Progress Publishers
7018. Beijing: Foreign Languages Press
7019. ??
7020. ??
7021. Kersplebedeb
7030. ??
7040. ??
7050. ??
7060. ??
7070. ??
7080. Trotsky deserting progressive cause / Trotskyist accidentally abandoning progressive cause (forsaking, deserting; motif) -> the thought experiment motif, or maybe in some texts the non-fictional motif, of Trotsky unintentionally turning his back on movements he logically should be in favor of, especially in reference to anything other than Stalin's government, although "Trotsky abandoning Soviet workers" would technically count too.
      is this violet? I kind of feel like it's crimson just because there were at least one or two entire books in the Soviet Union about this. I'll let it be orange but put in the tradition as ML or MX.
7081. If Panthers succeed Trotsky abandons them / If the Black Panthers succeeded Trotsky wouldn't like them and would insist on a different Marxist movement -> Ironblood setting related question; in this hypothetical scenario the Black Panthers do succeed, but Trotskyism is the most popular ideology in the United States, not anarchism. I am imagining this terrible anecdote where Trotsky thoughtlessly looks at the Black Panthers and is like, this is all wrong, they can't just fence off a socialism-in-one-country of Black people, we won't get to world revolution this way! and then somebody has to inform him he is basically being racist and he is like... oh. um. can there be multiple Trotskyist parties inside a world workers' state. I didn't think that far, I never thought of inventing meta-Marxism if I had any idea what that was. and the other Trotskyists make him agree to creating a better system where the United States will be divided up into five party-nations where people can join the one they wish and the states re-color themselves like in Liberalism. it's like, despite Trotsky moving to North America (and in this scenario eventually moving to New York, which only makes it funnier) he is so behind on United States issues it's always the US-born Trotskyists fixing things he probably would have screwed up.
7082. If LGBT+ support Stalin, Trotsky abandons them / If gay people support Stalin Trotsky abandons them -> Ironblood setting related question. the first "terrible anecdote" I imagined where basically as it says on the tin, a gay man sides with the Soviet Union, he has to put up with all the backward behavior there and hardly feeling like part of society, then Trotsky outright says in his face, well if you didn't support Stalin you wouldn't have to worry about this. in my imagination Luxemburg just kind of looks at him and is like Trotsky what the fuck (pronounced fuck) you can't just do that. some of these dumb ideas in my notes are early things I haven't "corrected" to be realistic, other things are intentional deviations from the timeline which would only make sense in context; Luxemburg being alive longer is one of the latter but also an artifact of me not having figured out who and where all the characters are so I toss in other characters as placeholders
7083. ??
7084. ??
7085. ??
7086. ??
7087. ??
7088. Trotsky deserting East Germany / Trotskyist deserting East Germany -> many of these refer to Trotskyists in general, only a few like the very specific Black Panther Party scenario are truly aimed at Trotsky. I have a habit of humorously calling all Trotskyists "Trotsky" but it most of the time meaning any Trotskyist theorist such as Ted Grant, James P. Cannon, etc. I hope that's clear.
7089. ??
7090. timeline where the International (pronounced International) is finished -> the motif of a hypothetical or fictional scenario where the goal of the First or Third International is actually achieved and every country transitions out of capitalism into something else which is at least not worse. field: meta-transitional realism
7091. ??
7092. Ironblood series -> basically just a reserved item
      motifs: Q70,90 timeline where the International is finished, etc.
7093. Aurora system / IronShard -> reserved, but closer to being real
7094. ??
7095. ??
7096. ??
7097. ??
7098. ??
7099. ??
7100. ??
7138. Helix Chamber
7200. ??
7250. ??
7270. ??
7271. Vegeta IV is worse than Vegeta III
7272. Vegeta III is worse than Vegeta IV -> this is the one I think was true, although both become irrelevant when the series reboots into Super
7300. ??
7301. [S] Android 1
7302. [S] Android 2
7303. [S] Android 3
7304. [S] Android 4
7305. [S] Android 5
7306. [S] Android 6
7307. [S] Android 7
7308. [S] Android 8
7309. [S] Android 9
7310. [S] Android 10
7311. [S] Android 11
7312. [S] Android 12
7313. [S] Android 13
7314. [S] Android 14
7315. [S] Android 15
7316. [S] Android 16
7317. [S] Android 17
7318. [S] Android 18
7319. [S] Android 19
7320. [S] Android 20
7321. [S] Android 21
7322. ??
7323. ??
7324. ??
7325. [S] Android 25
7326. [S] Android 26
7327. ??
7328. ??
7329. ??
7330. ??
7331. ??
7332. ??
7333. Android 33
7334. ??
7335. That time I got reincarnated as Yamcha
7336. Future Trunks timeline
7337. Trunks (Dragon Ball)
7338. Trunks' sword -> is it different from Z sword?
7339. ??
7340. ??
7341. ??
7342. ??
7343. ??
7344. Trotskyism is possible in Dragon Ball -> MDem 5.1. still amusing, still very thought-provoking.
7345. ??
7346. ??
7347. 15-generations-prior god-of-worlds
7348. Z sword (Dragon Ball)
7349. ??
7350. ??
7400. ??
7401. ??
7402. ??
7403. ??
7404. Super Saiyan 4 (GT)
7410. ??
7411. ??
7412. ??
7413. ??
7414. ??
7415. ??
7416. ??
7417. Android 17 (GT)
7450. ??
7500. Wings of Fire prequels
7501. empire plant -> I forget its name but that's what it is
7502. the king I can't remember
7503. Freedom
7504. castle lord guy
7505. Sky the SkyWing
7506. Wren -> until I looked it up I really couldn't remember her name and thought she was named after a plant like several other characters in that book
7507. Darkstalker -> there's a lot to say about Darkstalker and narrative parallels. the funniest one is his parallel to Death Note. the most unexpected one is his parallel to the description of LV in Undertale.
7508. Clearsight
7509. Book of Clearsight
7510. Dragonslayer
7511. Darkstalker
7512. Wings of Fire series
7513. Warriors series
7514. Guardians of Ga'Hoole series
7515. One for Sorrow, Two for Joy
7516. Kimba the White Lion / Jungle Emperor Leo -> move? not sure how many chapters there are
7520. ??
7532. there is only power and those who seek it -> appears in: Harry Potter
7533. ??
7599. the Raskolnikov -> I've seen three books with a Raskolnikov in them. Crime and Punishment itself. Death Note. The 13th Tribe, which is supposedly about a whole tiny group of Raskolnikovs.
7600. Epic of Gilgamesh
7601. Crime and Punishment -> the most notable thing about this book to me is that it was loosely adapted to create Death Note.
7602. Death Note
7603. Death Note (artifact)
7603. animus scroll (Wings of Fire)
7605. ??
7610. mistaken quest to steal immortality from the gods
7611. ??
7612. ??
7613. ??
7614. ??
7615. ??
7616. Undertale
7617. Deltarune
7618. ??
7619. ??
7620. ??
7625. ??
7630. ??
7635. ??
7640. ??
7645. ??
7650. ??
7651. ??
7652. ??
7653. Kolchak and Fennekin -> one of those motifs I didn't actually know the definition of at the moment I thought of the phrase and just put down because it was funny. um. this is the motif of Pokémon stories referencing the history of workers' states. something that I would never expect to happen in official Pokémon media but you know, motifs can be whatever even if they're entirely hypothetical. as long as in reference to works and motifs that already exist you can fully imagine what they'd look like if they did exist.
7654. ??
7662. SCP-6662 [9] -> lost cereal mascot seeking "own destination"
7663. ??
7665. Mx. Satan / Mr. Satan (motif) / White Witch (motif) -> when a character in a story is asserted to be a regular character within a world and not necessarily supernatural in the sense of having anything to do with gods, even the fictional gods of that secular fantasy narrative etc, but is really really clearly paralleling a Satan/antichrist narrative as you would see in the Christian bible. Mr. Satan - trope namer; ice queen (Narnia). really can be any gender.
7666. The enemy of one entity is the enemy of all humankind / The world only has one opposer / Satan fallacy -> fallacy best known in the Christian Bible, but repeated in many fantasy books. this statement fails the Trotsky model hard. if you think this statement could ever be true, then it could hypothetically be true that the enemy of Stalin's government is the enemy of all humankind. you've gotta put Trotsky to death to save Soviet civilization. and that's a pretty big contradiction to have in your philosophy for all First World countries. Trotsky is sacred. but if there's any such thing as Bible-style Good and Evil, he's done. which thing is correct? you can't change the Soviet Union to Liberalism to make the problem easier, you have to answer the moral conundrum exactly as it is.
7667. ??
7683. Would a Russia made of reactionaries deserve sovereignty? (composed of reactionaries; consisting only or solely of conservative bigots) / If every Russian is reactionary, do they deserve a government? / If every Russian was a reactionary, would it be acceptable for people in another country to assist in a plan to gut Russia of its government, install leaders chosen to interface well with the United States or Europe, and turn it into a client state? (Russia, China, Korea, Vietnam, Cuba, Iraq, Iran, etc; insert Third World nationality which has been "assigned conservative at birth"; insert country which has literally undergone this) -> this is a question to catch anarchist and center-Liberal Idealists that think they're "postcolonial" but by any reasonable Materialist definition are passively committing exocolonialism are and actually colonial. only if you say "no" can you genuinely have a postcolonial theory. if you say "yes", you can be an anarchist, Trotskyist, or Existentialist, but you are an imperialist. it is true that anyone who answers "no" to this question has a new contradiction to answer in what it's acceptable to do to a misbehaving country other than war or client state, but this is still a critical question that separates Marxism from Liberal-republicanism.
      Nazi Germany is a very special edge case which I will arbitrarily say is not part of this question because it's so difficult; it's a little hard to say what other than war is even possible there. I think it's important to have an answer so people don't get cornered back into this Item, but I think it belongs in its own question or proposition.
7684. Would you kill a Russian in order to vote? / Would you kill a Russian to receive your voter card? -> you live in an alternate world where every individual in the United States is entitled to a voting license the day they kill a Russian. policies are mostly the same. voting brings anti-discrimination laws, healthcare programs, whatever. but you have to kill someone in Eurasia to get to vote, or to get to tell anyone else to vote. want people to vote for gun control? every one of them has to fly over and shoot a Russian, and then you can have it. the central question of this thought experiment is this: how much is voting worth? what lengths is it worth going to just to preserve voting and the "normal" process of getting people to vote? would people chant "vote Democrat" as loudly if every one of them was required to kill a Russian? what about if voting Democrat really does take a little power away from Tories to create more structural racism and kill Black people? should everyone go kill a Russian just to save Black people from fascism? or is preserving the life of Russians more important than that aim? the only thing about this metaphor that's incoherent to me is how you prove anyone actually killed anyone. uh. maybe there are a limited number of voter licenses, and you'd just take one from Russia and hold it up. or maybe everyone has an ID card which clearly has a flag on it and you'd take that. there may or may not be a system where any country can kill people to issue voter licenses but just as in real life most countries are too afraid to attack the United States. also you equally get a point if you kill a United States Communist and it can be proven in court, even though they deliberately don't have different id card flags. in this world people go to court to prove they have done approved heinous things as well as to prove they're innocent.
7685. ??
7686. ??
7687. PragerU / Prager University
7688. Fox News
7689. ??
7690. ??
7691. A bunch of people passing a law can stop all bad guys from ever being bad guys -> from a video that will not be named to preserve the integrity of the YouTube community guidelines reporting system. I can't believe people actually think this way about AI in an age of federal war against immigrants. this kind of thinking didn't even successfully knock Trump out of office for committing crimes, he just got impeached and nothing happened. I have started reporting videos like this for White supremacy. they refuse to acknowledge the possibility that billionaires will openly attack the population as material people just because the population tries to pass a law against them they sufficiently don't like or will dismantle components of government anti-Third-World style, they get reported. I don't know if my reports will do anything, but I can try.
7692. ??
7693. portraying negative phenomenon without recommending it / ironic phenomenon
7694. unironic misogyny
7695. ironic misogyny -> see: Dragon Ball
7696. heteronormativity
7697. ironic heteronormativity -> see: Amy Rose, DHMIS "Malcom"
7698. normalcy of relationships proved by Lived Experiences / gay relationships are normal
7699. normalcy of gender proved by Lived Experiences / transgender identity is normal
7700. ??
7700. Journey to the West
7701. golden light
7702. fictional religious cosmology -> Girl from the other side; Warriors / StarClan
7703. evil god takes form as the earth -> Tiamat; hinduism?
7704. cosmic graph struggle
7735. Yamcha (Dragon Ball)
7742. understanding the universe
7743. karma (spatial rank)
7744. bailing someone out of system
7745. bailing someone out of supernatural system
7746. bailing someone out of karma
7747. Saiyans losing tails -> lore significance specifically
7747. ??
7748. ??
7771. Sonic the Hedgehog
7772. Tails
7773. Knuckles
7774. Amy Rose -> what is misogyny?
7775. (sonic character)
7776. (sonic character)
7777. Shadow the Hedgehog
7778. [S] MarioCube / MarioCube theory
7779. Black Arms
7780. GUN -> planetary police, planetary army
7781. ??
7782. Sonic × Shadow / Sonadow -> Group Subject containing: Sonic, Shadow
7783. ??
7783. VIZ media
7784. Bird Studio
7785. Sega
7786. ??
7787. Funtime Shenron -> "eternal dragon" or other character/device that claims to grant you a wish but actually just eats you or takes your dead body. perfectly okay to give this a different primary label, I just think "Funtime Shenlong" is a really funny image
7788. ??
7793. Steel Wool games
7794. ??
7795. ??
7796. ??
7797. ??
7798. Children are composed almost entirely of memories / Children are a shard off their parents' memories / Children are a fork off their parents' inner timeline of Lived Experiences -> Lacanianism; Charlie (Fourth Closet); Girl from the other side
7799. Girl From the Other Side (all media) / Other Side / Girl from the Outside (typo) / The Outsiders (typo)
7870. (... Girl From the Other Side)
7900. ??
7965. Ultra Q (1966)
7966. Ultraman (1966)
7967. Ultraseven (1967)
7968. The Return of Ultraman (1971) / Ultraman Jack (show)
7969. Ultraman Ace (1972)
7970. Ultraman Taro (1973)
7971. The☆Ultraman (1979) / Ultraman Joneus (show)
7972. Ultraman 80 (1980)
7973. Ultraman Zearth (1996)
7974. Ultraman Leo (1973) -> features signifier: Leon Trotsky counterpart
7975. ??
7976. ??
7977. ??
7978. ??
7979. ??
7980. ??
7981. ??
7982. ??
7983. ??
7984. ??
7985. ??
7986. ??
7987. ??
7988. ??
7989. ??
7990. Ultraman Geed (2017) -> this one was so questionable, it was like, nazi-framed Ultraman show
7991. ??
7992. ??
7993. ??
7994. ??
7995. ??
7996. ??
7997. ??
7998. ??
7999. Slay the Princess
8000. ??
8151. Pokémon (metaseries)
8190. virtual pet form / virtual pet stage / evolution stage / Pokémon kind / Pokédex kind
8191. virtual pet form tier / evolution stage
8192. virtual pet species / virtual pet strain / virtual pet form chart (internal mechanic)
8193. reused virtual pet form / virtual pet form switching from one series of forms to another / track switch / trackswitch
8194. ??
8195. ??
8196. ??
8197. Digimon (metaseries)
8198. ??
8199. ??
8200. ??
8326. neopets
8327. neopet -> toon-style being, LCD-style being, Subject-style being; medium: virtual pet; only really here to demonstrate categories
8328. ??
8329. The Mimic was hiding in every game as Jackie
8330. The Mimic was hiding inside Shadow Freddy
8331. MCI victim names / Gabriel (??) / Jeremy (??) / Fritz (??) / Susie (??) / Susie (Return to the Pit)
8332. Golden Freddy contains "The one you should not have killed"
8333. Golden Freddy DOES NOT contain "The one you should not have killed"
8334. Michael became Old Man Consequences
8335. Henry became Old Man Consequences
8336. Ralph became Old Man Consequences -> reliving old traumas in cyclic timeline (FNaF)
8337. Andrew, Jake, and Stitchwraith are in games / StitchlineGames
8338. Tales from the Pizzaplex takes place in games setting / TalesGames
8339. Michael Afton was protagonist of FNaF 1-4 / The Box contains Foxy mask
8340. Chica was created during Fredbear era
8341. Toy animatronics originated from Fall Fest / Toy animatronic characters first shown at carnival
8342. Mangle came from carnival ride / Mangle is not Funtime Foxy / Mangle first shown at Fall Fest
8343. The Mimic copied William Afton to create Glitchtrap
8344. Every instance of The Mimic is networked together
8345. Carnie was built out of LEFTE (pronounced LEFTE)
8346. Cassidy died in springlock incident -> red lakes and drowning imagery
8347. Fazbear Enterprises is responsible for bringing back Fall Fest
8348. Tiger Rock plush is a counterpart to the books
8349. Desk guy counts as Henry because he is based on Scott / Scott is desk guy is Henry -> FNaF World
8350. LEFTE (pronounced LEFTE) contains five dead kids / LefteDCI / LeftyDCI -> 1 2
8351. Circus Baby is not William's creation but Henry's revenge on William -> Circus Baby - based on - Charlie; "the baby is not mine"
8352. There are actually multiple William Aftons from different timelines
8353. Candy Cadet is contrasting Circus Baby's plan with Henry's plan / Candy Cadet is contrasting Sister Location's worst ending with Pizza Simulator's best ending
8354. Helpy is a Funtime because the Pizza Place is Henry's version of the Funtimes intended to catch Funtimes
8355. William based the Funtime animatronics on LEFTE (pronounced LEFTE) -> I think this is slightly "anachronistic" because Baby existed at the time of the fire, but it's definitely fun, and it creates a nice transition between FNaF 6 and The Fourth Closet
8356. Henry and William are in an arms race / Whenever Henry builds something William appropriates it for evil / When William builds something Henry appropriates it for good
8357. Michael is "The one you should not have killed" and UCN was Michael's revenge -> this implies that "The vengeful spirit" is not "The one you should not have killed" because the ghost voice and Michael would be two different characters - both tormenting William.
8358. William Afton deliberately made the Funtimes able to feel pain in order to harvest Agony -> strangely enough, actually becomes more plausible on Jackie's timeline where the Mimics seem to have pre-dated Freddy Fazbear
8359. Dave Afton longed for Fredbear to protect him and possession granted him his wish -> [10]
8360. Fazbear Frights is an in-universe series created by Fazbear Entertainment -> different from the concept of Security Breach timeline vs classic timeline; some argue Frights is too insulting to Fazbear Entertainment - [11]
8361. The mound in Midnight Motorist contains a hidden Twisted One waiting to strike -> man I love the creativity. I don't think there is any serious Silver Eyes in the games before Security Breach but the image is hilarious
8362. ??
8400. forest beings turning into trees -> QID references: SCP.
8401. ??
8443. Lenin counterpart -> also in: Ultraman Leo
8444. Leon Trotsky counterpart / Emmanuel Goldstein / Snowball -> also in: Ultraman Leo
8445. Rosa Luxemburg counterpart
8453. Joseph Stalin counterpart / Napoleon (pig)
8454. Pigs (Animal Farm)
8500. ??
8501. Pyrrhia
8509. dragon tribe
8510. dragon (Wings of Fire)
8511. MudWing
8512. SeaWing
8513. RainWing
8514. NightWing
8515. SandWing
8516. moon-touched dragon
8517. Icewing
8518. SkyWing
8519. animus magic
8520. dragon created through animus magic -> there are about three in the series: Boa, fake Clearsight, Peacemaker. notably, Darkstalker is responsible for two of them.
8521. SilkWing
8522. Hivewing
8523. LeafWing
8524. flamesilk dragon
8525. Boa / Jerboa (construct)
8526. hybrid dragon
8527. animus dragon
8528. firescales
8550. ??
8600. ??
8650. ??
8700. Dragon Ball (metaseries)
8701. Dragon Ball (first era)
8702. Dragon Ball (Z era)
8703. Dragon Ball Super (era)
8704. ??
8705. Dragon Ball prequels (era)
8706. Sonic the Hedgehog (2006)
8707. ??
8708. ??
8709. ??
8710. ??
8711. ??
8712. ??
8771. Sonic the Hedgehog (metaseries)
8772. ??
8773. ??
8774. ??
8775. "I am all of me" (song)
8776. "This is who I am" (song)
8777. Shadow the Hedgehog (2005)
8778. "Live and Learn" (song)